Heya,

Thanks for the KIP!

I am not convinced that making
--bootstrap-server/--bootstrap-controller optional in kafka-features
is needed. I understand that there is a difference with how
kafka-storage works, but the two CLIs are meant to be used in
different situations - kafka-storage is meant to be used during a
setup leading to a working cluster while kafka-features allows dynamic
interactions with an already working cluster. I further understand
that you might want to use this tool in an automation, but I don't
quite understand to what purpose - this isn't dynamic information i.e.
it will only change during a new release and you can just point to
that release's kafka-storage tool to get the same information, no?

I am more intrigued by the second part of the KIP. As far as I am
understanding it, you would like to see what features are unstable, or
at least which version numbers of a feature are unstable so that you
don't enable them accidentally?

Best,
Christo

Reply via email to