Hi Igor,
Thanks for the KIP!
1.
Could you please elaborate why prefixing the application.id with the
team's topic namespace is not always desirable. I would like to better
understand the motivation of this KIP.
2.
Could you please add type and default value for the proposed config
internal.topics.prefix?
Something like
"internal.topics.prefix"
type: string
default: "" (empty string)
Similar would be also great for the proposed argument for the Streams
resetter tool.
3.
Could you please add a test plan to the KIP?
4.
Could you please add a JIRA ticket (if one does not already exist) and
link it to the KIP?
Best,
Bruno
On 06.07.23 13:14, Igor Buzatovic wrote:
Hi everyone,
I would like to start a discussion on the following KIP:
KIP-948: Allow custom prefix for internal topic names in Kafka Streams
https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/KAFKA/KIP-948%3A+Allow+custom+prefix+for+internal+topic+names+in+Kafka+Streams
The goal is to provide greater flexibility in naming internal topics. The
main issue is that it affects Kafka Streams application reset tool (as
described in the KIP), so I guess the pros and cons should be weighed to
decide if this proposal makes sense.
Your feedback is appreciated. Thanks!
Igor Buzatović
Porsche Digital Croatia d.o.o.
