Hello Hive community,

The Hive project is struggling to perform its security duties[0]: there are
unusually old security reports that the Hive Security Team / PMC has not
disclosed yet, and triaging new incoming security reports also takes longer
than responsible. This not only falls short of what is expected as an
Apache project, but longer-term could have legal consequences for the ASF
and individual contributors, with legislation such as the CRA coming into
force in Europe and similar measures being expected around the world.

The ASF Security Team has expressed its concern before, leading to the
first formal escalation step [1] of issuing a call for help on your public
mailinglist [2] back in March, after an earlier call by your PMC in
September [3]. This yielded one volunteer. As far as I can tell the PMC has
not enlisted this volunteer yet.

If the Hive project cannot return to a healthy cadence of dealing with
security issues, the only responsible decision for the PMC (which is
collectively responsible for the oversight of the project) would be to
initiate the move to the Attic. Of course we hope this can be prevented.


Kind regards,

Arnout Engelen
ASF Security Team

[0] https://apache.org/security/committers.html
[1]
https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/SECURITY/Project+Security+Response+Formal+Escalation
[2] https://lists.apache.org/thread/8wghsxdlj8bfygf2ptcdb8pojlvxwjx8
[3] https://lists.apache.org/thread/j0ztt61wjz9gc46dj6fpor30xh437h9n

Reply via email to