Hi Timo,

Re 1) I agree. I renamed the title to "Extend Core Table System with
Pluggable Modules" and all internal references

Re 2) First, I'll rename the API to useModules(). The design doesn't forbid
users to call useModules() multi times. Objects in modules are loaded on
demand instead of eagerly, so there won't be inconsistency. Users have to
be fully aware of the consequences of resetting modules as that might cause
that some objects can not be referenced anymore or resolution order of some
objects changes.

Re 3) Yes, we'd leave that to users.

Another approach can be to have a non-optional "Core" module for all
objects that cannot be overrode like "CAST" and "AS" functions, and have an
optional "ExtendedCore" module for other replaceable built-in objects.
"Core" should be positioned at the 1st in module list all the time.

I'm fine with either solution.

Re 4) It may sound like a nice-to-have advanced feature for 1.10, but we
can surely fully discuss it for the sake of feature completeness.

Unlike other configs, the order of modules would matter in Flink, and it
implies the LOAD/UNLOAD commands would not be equal in operation positions.
IIUYC, LOAD MODULE 'x' would be interpreted as appending x to the end of
module list, and UNLOAD MODULE 'x' would be interpreted as removing x from
any position in the list?

I'm thinking of the following list of commands:

SHOW MODULES - list modules in order
LOAD MODULE 'hive' [WITH ('prop'='myProp', ...)] - load and append the
module to end of the module list
UNLOAD MODULE 'hive' - remove the module from module list, and other
modules remain the same relative positions
USE MODULES 'x' 'y' 'z' (wondering can parser take "'x' 'y' 'z'"?), or USE
MODULES 'x,y,z' - to reorder module list completely

Reply via email to