Hello. Referring to https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/MATH-1346
The class mostly adds a trivial layer (for a subset of the distributions available in CM) around "RandomDataGenerator" (which itself was a trivial layer around the sampling API directly provided by the distribution classes). "RandomDataGenerator" will disappear, the non-trivial functionality being replaced by "RandomUtils" (cf. MATH-1341). Hence, "ValueServer", being the sole remaining class in CM that depend on "RandomDataGenerator" would need to be modified. However, AFAICT, functionality in "ValueServer" is either duplicating similar functionality available elsewhere in CM (e.g. "fill" vs "sample" in "AbstractRealDistribution") or some trivial task that should not be bothered with by CM (e.g. read a file line by line and convert its content to a "double"[1]). Did I miss some unique contribution of this code? IOW, can someone come up with a case that would require a "ValueServer" object in new applications in preference to the alternative, direct, way for getting the same functionality? If not, I propose to deprecate this class. [As usual, old applications can always keep a dependency to CM v3.x if they use "ValueServer".] Regards, Gilles [1] Obviously, this has nothing to do with random data generation. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@commons.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@commons.apache.org