On 30 March 2015 at 23:45, Reto Gmür <r...@apache.org> wrote: > Hi all, > > The clerezza commons RDF proposal that was in the sandbox and is now in the > clerezza-rdf-core repository has been changed to use > org.apache.clerezza.commons-rdf. > > As you know if all goes well clerezza will be based in the result of the > incubating project. If however this project should unfortunately not lead > to something generic enough to be used for interfacing arbitrary data as > RDF and thus be usable for clerezza, then clerezza might reactivate its > commons-rdf proposal. It would then be up to commons to decide which > proposal to adopt and under which name.
The project is not designed with "interfacing arbitrary data as RDF" in mind, so it is unlikely it will suit Clerezza if that is what you are aiming for Clerezza Commons RDF to do for its internal purposes. It is aimed at representing the RDF-1.1 Abstract Data Model using Java interfaces. Designing around interfaces should theoretically be the lowest common denominator for attaching to any existing project, and it isn't clear why it wouldn't work for you. Also keep in mind that we are not expecting any project to internally rely on the API we are providing here. The main goal is interoperability at the external facing parts of each implementation, not changing the core models that each implementation uses internally. What exactly do you mean by "reactivate" the clerezza commons-rdf proposal? All that happened previously was that you followed the Commons suggestion for any Apache committer to unilaterally add modules arbitrarily to Apache Commons. There was, and is, no bilateral support for your actions and threatening to propose an alternative, again...... > Till then I would prefer this project to use a group ID outside > org.apache.commons. We should probably resolve this now. There is no point to changing the group ID in the future and Reto has threatened an alternative (again) to support the proposal to not have this project use the standard convention. Peter --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@commons.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@commons.apache.org
