Hi Thomas,

thanks a lot for your help, very appreciated! :)

> Critical
>
>  * FILEUPLOAD-212: after looking more carefully into it I think it is
>    invalid, see the attached test
>

+1 I'd close it as `not a problem`

>  * FILEUPLOAD-193: as stated in the comments already, this was most
>    likely due to some non-supported filenames in a windows environment
>    can be resolved as Invalid I guess
>

yeah as above, it is a specific environment problem

> Major
>
>  * FILEUPLOAD-205: I think we should fix this, I outlined a possible
>    fix in the comments.
>

looks like you already have an idea how to handle it - do you feel
comfortable on checkin-in the fix?

>  * FILEUPLOAD-199: we could copy the MimeUtility class (under CDDL
>    license) and decode the header values with it, similar as we encode
>    them in commons-email.
>

+1

>  * FILEUPLOAD-206: supporting content encoding for form-data would be
>    really helpful I guess
>
> additionally, I resolved some more issues as duplicates of others, and
> provided some comments on others which I tried to reproduce but failed.
>

I haven't checked all of them - did you add 1.3 in the `fix version` field?

> We should also validate if FILEUPLOAD-188 is fixed by introducing the
> new contentLength() method which returns a long.
>
> btw. I am unsure about this change, as it now only looks at the
> Content-Length header. If none is set, the result it -1, but before we
> were returning request.getContentLength().

as you stated in FILEUPLOAD-179 I agree that "If none is present -1 is
returned, so I guess it would be better that in this case the old
"request.getContentLength()" is returned."

thanks,
-Simo

http://people.apache.org/~simonetripodi/
http://simonetripodi.livejournal.com/
http://twitter.com/simonetripodi
http://www.99soft.org/

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@commons.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@commons.apache.org

Reply via email to