Paul, not much reaction so far, :( I would prefer to have them both be installed separately when I `require cloudstack` or `<tool> install cloudstack`, but still be able to install them separately if i want them on different machines i.e. `install cloudstack-management` or alternatively `install cloudstack-engine and `install cloudstack-ui`.
ad 1: +1 from me ad 2: as said rather a virtual package that depends on both. I think the direct dependency is wrong, but we're a bit late in the process. I'm not sure if we can take the time to properly implement this over all systems, given the input so far. I'd go for the dependency of the ui on the engine as a temporary solution. On Thu, Dec 3, 2020 at 7:09 PM <pau...@apache.org> wrote: > PMC members, PLEASE ONLY RESPOND ON THE DEV THREAD. > > > > Hi all, > > > > Please read all of this, I know it's a bit wordy.. > > > > We're pretty much there wrt to RC1 of CloudStack and the updated UI. We > have one issue remaining, and that is about the packaging and voting on > CloudStack 'engine' and its UI. > > The UI has been developed asynchronously, but at time of a CloudStack > release, we really need to be able have definite link between the two > codebases so that we release 'one thing' when we release CloudStack. > > > > A while back, I created a proposal [1], which I'd like to again put forward > as the default process unless there are any objections. > > > > In addition; > > > > 1. I think that the repo 'apache/cloudstack-primate' should be renamed to > '/apache/cloudstack-ui', to keep everything just 'cloudstack'. > > > > 2. In the repo RPM/DEB packaging make cloudstack-ui a dependency of > cloudstack - and finally, when creating the repo, include both the > 'cloudstack' and 'cloudstack-ui' RPMs/DEBs so that there is one repo > (http://download.cloudstack.org/centos7/4.15/) which contains both. > > > > PS - PMC members, PLEASE ONLY RESPOND ON THE DEV THREAD. > > > > [1] > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=165222727 > > > > Kind regards > > > > Paul Angus > > -- Daan
