Github user DaanHoogland commented on a diff in the pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/cloudstack/pull/1403#discussion_r62875666
  
    --- Diff: 
engine/storage/datamotion/src/org/apache/cloudstack/storage/motion/StorageSystemDataMotionStrategy.java
 ---
    @@ -255,99 +473,123 @@ private Void 
handleCreateVolumeFromSnapshotBothOnStorageSystem(SnapshotInfo snap
     
                 VolumeApiResult result = future.get();
     
    +            if (volumeDetail != null) {
    +                _volumeDetailsDao.remove(volumeDetail.getId());
    +            }
    +
                 if (result.isFailed()) {
    -                s_logger.debug("Failed to create a volume: " + 
result.getResult());
    +                s_logger.warn("Failed to create a volume: " + 
result.getResult());
     
                     throw new CloudRuntimeException(result.getResult());
                 }
    -        }
    -        catch (Exception ex) {
    -            throw new CloudRuntimeException(ex.getMessage());
    -        }
     
    -        volumeInfo = _volumeDataFactory.getVolume(volumeInfo.getId(), 
volumeInfo.getDataStore());
    +            volumeInfo = _volumeDataFactory.getVolume(volumeInfo.getId(), 
volumeInfo.getDataStore());
     
    -        volumeInfo.processEvent(Event.MigrationRequested);
    +            volumeInfo.processEvent(Event.MigrationRequested);
     
    -        volumeInfo = _volumeDataFactory.getVolume(volumeInfo.getId(), 
volumeInfo.getDataStore());
    +            volumeInfo = _volumeDataFactory.getVolume(volumeInfo.getId(), 
volumeInfo.getDataStore());
     
    -        HostVO hostVO = getHost(snapshotInfo.getDataStore().getId());
    -
    -        String value = 
_configDao.getValue(Config.PrimaryStorageDownloadWait.toString());
    -        int primaryStorageDownloadWait = NumbersUtil.parseInt(value, 
Integer.parseInt(Config.PrimaryStorageDownloadWait.getDefaultValue()));
    -        CopyCommand copyCommand = new CopyCommand(snapshotInfo.getTO(), 
volumeInfo.getTO(), primaryStorageDownloadWait, 
VirtualMachineManager.ExecuteInSequence.value());
    +            if (useCloning) {
    +                copyCmdAnswer = performResignature(volumeInfo, hostVO);
    +            }
    +            else {
    +                // asking for a XenServer host here so we don't always 
prefer to use XenServer hosts that support resigning
    +                // even when we don't need those hosts to do this kind of 
copy work
    +                hostVO = getHost(snapshotInfo.getDataCenterId(), false);
     
    -        CopyCmdAnswer copyCmdAnswer = null;
    +                copyCmdAnswer = performCopyOfVdi(volumeInfo, snapshotInfo, 
hostVO);
    +            }
     
    -        try {
    -            _volumeService.grantAccess(snapshotInfo, hostVO, 
snapshotInfo.getDataStore());
    -            _volumeService.grantAccess(volumeInfo, hostVO, 
volumeInfo.getDataStore());
    +            if (copyCmdAnswer == null || !copyCmdAnswer.getResult()) {
    +                if (copyCmdAnswer != null && 
!StringUtils.isEmpty(copyCmdAnswer.getDetails())) {
    +                    errMsg = copyCmdAnswer.getDetails();
    +                }
    +                else {
    +                    errMsg = "Unable to create volume from snapshot";
    +                }
    +            }
    +        }
    +        catch (Exception ex) {
    +            errMsg = ex.getMessage() != null ? ex.getMessage() : "Copy 
operation failed";
    +        }
     
    -            Map<String, String> srcDetails = 
getSnapshotDetails(_storagePoolDao.findById(snapshotInfo.getDataStore().getId()),
 snapshotInfo);
    +        CopyCommandResult result = new CopyCommandResult(null, 
copyCmdAnswer);
     
    -            copyCommand.setOptions(srcDetails);
    +        result.setResult(errMsg);
     
    -            Map<String, String> destDetails = getVolumeDetails(volumeInfo);
    +        callback.complete(result);
    +    }
     
    -            copyCommand.setOptions2(destDetails);
    +    /**
    +     * If the underlying storage system is making use of read-only 
snapshots, this gives the storage system the opportunity to
    +     * create a volume from the snapshot so that we can copy the VHD file 
that should be inside of the snapshot to secondary storage.
    +     *
    +     * The resultant volume must be writable because we need to resign the 
SR and the VDI that should be inside of it before we copy
    +     * the VHD file to secondary storage.
    +     *
    +     * If the storage system is using writable snapshots, then nothing 
need be done by that storage system here because we can just
    +     * resign the SR and the VDI that should be inside of the snapshot 
before copying the VHD file to secondary storage.
    +     */
    +    private void createVolumeFromSnapshot(HostVO hostVO, SnapshotInfo 
snapshotInfo, boolean keepGrantedAccess) {
    +        SnapshotDetailsVO snapshotDetails = 
handleSnapshotDetails(snapshotInfo.getId(), "tempVolume", "create");
     
    -            copyCmdAnswer = (CopyCmdAnswer)_agentMgr.send(hostVO.getId(), 
copyCommand);
    -        }
    -        catch (Exception ex) {
    -            throw new CloudRuntimeException(ex.getMessage());
    +        try {
    +            
snapshotInfo.getDataStore().getDriver().createAsync(snapshotInfo.getDataStore(),
 snapshotInfo, null);
             }
             finally {
    -            try {
    -                _volumeService.revokeAccess(snapshotInfo, hostVO, 
snapshotInfo.getDataStore());
    -            }
    -            catch (Exception ex) {
    -                s_logger.debug(ex.getMessage(), ex);
    -            }
    -
    -            try {
    -                _volumeService.revokeAccess(volumeInfo, hostVO, 
volumeInfo.getDataStore());
    -            }
    -            catch (Exception ex) {
    -                s_logger.debug(ex.getMessage(), ex);
    -            }
    +            _snapshotDetailsDao.remove(snapshotDetails.getId());
             }
     
    -        String errMsg = null;
    +        CopyCmdAnswer copyCmdAnswer = performResignature(snapshotInfo, 
hostVO, keepGrantedAccess);
     
             if (copyCmdAnswer == null || !copyCmdAnswer.getResult()) {
    -            if (copyCmdAnswer != null && copyCmdAnswer.getDetails() != 
null && !copyCmdAnswer.getDetails().isEmpty()) {
    -                errMsg = copyCmdAnswer.getDetails();
    +            if (copyCmdAnswer != null && 
!StringUtils.isEmpty(copyCmdAnswer.getDetails())) {
    +                throw new 
CloudRuntimeException(copyCmdAnswer.getDetails());
                 }
                 else {
    -                errMsg = "Unable to perform host-side operation";
    +                throw new CloudRuntimeException("Unable to create volume 
from snapshot");
                 }
             }
    +    }
     
    -        CopyCommandResult result = new CopyCommandResult(null, 
copyCmdAnswer);
    +    /**
    +     * If the underlying storage system needed to create a volume from a 
snapshot for createVolumeFromSnapshot(HostVO, SnapshotInfo), then
    +     * this is its opportunity to delete that temporary volume and restore 
properties in snapshot_details to the way they were before the
    --- End diff --
    
    isn't the opportunity the at the caller of this method instead of in here?
    
    I don't see this javadoc as an added value here, especially as it is on a 
private method. It seems more of a maintenance burden.


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastruct...@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

Reply via email to