On 17-07-15 16:50, sebgoa wrote: > > On Jul 17, 2015, at 10:53 AM, Wido den Hollander <w...@widodh.nl> wrote: > >> Hi, >> >> Issue: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-8640 >> >> I encountered this by using the AWS SDK under 4.5 (homebrew). >> >> 4.5 uses the 1.3.22 SDK, but master uses 1.9.8 and that breaks S3 uploads. >> >> AWS SDK 1.3.22 is old, very old, but 1.9.8 is also rather old. >> >> The new SDK throws different Event Types and we can't simply fix a >> "else" statement since I tried and it failed. >> >> The S3TemplateDownloader was written in 2013, but imho it is a poor >> implementation which is rather buggy. >> >> It will need some work to get it working with the new AWS SDK however. >> >> Amazon in the meantime also started to switch to the new V4 Signature >> for Authorization, but that isn't supported yet by projects like Ceph's >> RADOS Gateway and probably by other S3 providers. >> >> So this seems like a blocker for 4.6, since we would ship a broken S3 >> implementation we know about. >> >> We can revert to the 1.3.22 AWS SDK, but I don't know the reasoning >> behind the switch to the 1.9.8 SDK. >> >> This was done in fac7bfc5d503aa25a82a684f7ec545197d255fb2 by Rohit, but >> I'm not sure if it was properly tested. >> >> The best route would be to fix the S3TemplateDownloader, I agree, but >> that would take a lot more time. > > I we talked about it for the roadmap, and Francois Gaudreault is also > interested to get this better supported. > > If you can edit the roadmap with the bug ID that would help, at least to > track it down. > > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/CLOUDSTACK/Roadmap >
Done! Added it. Wido > thanks > >> >> Wido >
