All,

While reviewing the solidfire patch, I noticed that a dummy getter/setter 
implementations with TODO comments in the PrimaryDataStoreImpl in  were merged 
into master.  I have opened a defect [1] for this issue, as the code will not 
work as expected (they are not actually working with the internal state of the 
object as expected).  

Speaking generally, every review I have performed for 4.2.0 has contained TODO 
comments, as well, tab characters and improper indentation.  Please check 
patches for these issues before submission.  For me, patches with TODOs are an 
immediate -1 because it conveys that the implementation is incomplete.  The 
formatting issues are minor, but easily rectified with a quick code format in 
an IDE.  

Thanks,
-John

[1]: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-3277

Reply via email to