> Ok, wrt G1 default, this is won't go ahead for 4.1-rc1 > > We can revisit it for 4.1.x > > We have a lot of voices here adamantly positive for it, and those of us that > have done the performance testing over the years know why. But being called > to prove it is totally valid, if you have data to any such tests please add > them to the ticket 18027
Revisiting. Are there any vetoes to making G1 the default (and updating the G1 settings, see the patch on https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CASSANDRA-18027 ) for 4.1.1 ? IIUC , the summary of this thread till now was: there were no vetoes to the change in trunk, but there were vetoes to 4.1.0 (because we were inside the beta to GA window), and there was a desire to have benchmarking data presented. WRT benchmarking, we have a separate thread for performance testing in the project. The ticket admittedly does not do its due diligence on data presentation and analysis of smaller heaps: a precedent we should be creating; but instead relies upon experience from many. Are we ok with this this time around, or shall the patch only be applied to trunk (where we have no choice w/ jdk17 landing)?
