I missed the end of Josh's email that suggested engaging here and the doc doesn't allow comments anyways so some more questions / thoughts here:
- Regarding the PMC roll call, is there any definition of "active on the project and want to participate"? - Will the PMC roll call apply to the PMC itself? That was my original read of it but looking closer, its an email to dev@. - 24 hour periods seem a little short, especially on the weekends - The bar regarding code review: I am generally +1 on requiring more eyes on code review. Two areas that I think could use clarification: for low-risk patches like test fixes, etc it may be too strong and for high risk patches the caveat that the author can be a reviewer if also a committer is too weak. I'll start with those 4 to limit the potential branching of this thread. Jordan On Thu, Jun 4, 2020 at 12:06 PM Jordan West <jw...@apache.org> wrote: > Glad to see the PMC has been discussing these topics and is making efforts > towards improving on the status quo. Thanks for sharing the draft. I'll > leave more detailed questions/comments on the doc itself but as a whole its > encouraging to see the PMC rely more heavily on the community and make an > effort to keep its view of active participants current. > > Jordan > > On Thu, Jun 4, 2020 at 9:54 AM Joshua McKenzie <jmcken...@apache.org> > wrote: > >> Hello project! >> >> The pmc has been discussing how we make decisions as a pmc, how we make >> decisions as a project of committers and contributors, what decisions are >> made where, and how those decisions are ratified and by whom. We came to >> the conclusion that there's value in having a more formal (though >> lightweight) structure around these topics as well as start to enumerate >> some expectations on how we interact with each other on the project as it >> matures. >> >> A link to the current draft of the governance doc is here: >> >> https://docs.google.com/document/d/1wOrJBkgudY2BxEVtubq9IbiFFC3d3efJSj9OIrGcqQ8/edit# >> >> The doc is only 2 pages long; if you're interested in engaging in a >> discussion about how we evolve and collaborate as a project, please take >> some time to read through the doc, think through things, and engage on >> this >> thread here. >> >> Thanks everyone, and looking forward to a great discussion! >> >> ~Josh McKenzie >> >
