Dear Arrow maintainers,

Sorry if this was raised before. I did search the mailing list but "C++" 
matched too many results..

With manylinux1 (GCC4.8) being sunset, both Conda and Pypa are providing a 
modern enough toolchain (Conda Forge - GCC7; Pypa manylinux2010 docker - 
devtoolset-8(GCC8)). And full C++17 support has been included in GCC7 [1]. I 
wonder what are the concerns of adopting a newer standard?
 
C++14 might not bring a whole lot of interesting features, but C++17 brings:

std::string_view
std::optional
std::variant (the newly added Result class is based on some form of variant 
implementation I suppose?)

and many syntax sugar.. (like emplace_back() returning back(), so you can do 
RETURN_NOT_OK(CreateArray(my_array_sp_vector.emplace_back())))

And btw, was -std=gnu++11 an intentional choice? what gnu extensions does the 
library rely on?

[1] https://gcc.gnu.org/projects/cxx-status.html

Reply via email to