On Sat, 6 Jun 2026 at 14:54, Stefan Bodewig <[email protected]> wrote:

>
> > I am sorry to say, but it seems that you did not even try, just blamed it
> > on the "xooki" CSS tag and dismissed it.
>
> I don't have the slightest clue what it does and it does something to
> the javascript in a template written for a template engine I'm not
> familiar with at all. And the PR description gives no justification why
> it should be there.
>
> Right.
>

So now you're blaming the PR title rather than reading the commit message.


> > Ruby helper sets the CSS tags (yes, "xooki" lives there by name only).
>
> It set the id to a different value than before and I don't understand
> why.
>

Because a certain list item needs to be highlighted.


> > The rest is a cleanup of CSS and elimination of some bitmap images which
> > should improve performance in modern browsers.
>
> It also adds a selector for treeview that hasn't been there before which
> is not my understanding of cleanup.


It does not. hitarea was there before.

> Should I provide a writeup in the comment to the PR?
>
> Not for me, I'm out. You will find somebody else to review it, I guess.
>
> In general for me a PR should say what it does - and why in case this
> isn't obvious. And not do anythng that it doesn't say it would do. And
> not do anything like "cleanup" when it wants to do anything other than
> cleanup as well. That's just me and this is not new and you already knew
> that. :-)


In this case, the cleanup means just that. I updated the title of the PR.

Gintas

Reply via email to