On Tuesday 18 November 2003 14:27, Christopher Lenz wrote: > peter reilly wrote: > > On Monday 17 November 2003 17:20, Dominique Devienne wrote: > >>Slightly related, if I extracted or wrote a schema for Ant, > >>and specified an xsi:schemaLocation attribute in <project>, > >>will Ant ignore the attribute, or barf? > > > > If the class did not contain a setSchemaLocation() method or > > was an instance of DynamicConfigurable it would barf. > > Well, Ant should check namespaces on attributes. I'm not sure whether > you've committed a related change already, but anywhere here's my > proposal for a simple rule: > > If the attribute has no namespace (not to be confused with it being in > the default namespace), or the namespace URI of the attribute matches > the namespace URI of the containing element, Ant uses the attribute to > configure the underlying object (via introspection or > DynamicConfigurator). Otherwise, the attribute should be ignored (or > possibly handled specially, like maybe the 'ant-type' attribute).
Yep, this is the way I intended to handle the attributes. > > > My original namespace support only allowed "antlib:*" to > > be used for typedef's uri attribute (and hence antlib), all > > other namespace uri's were ignored - see for example: > > http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=ant-dev&m=105336417419712&w=2 > > Such an artificial limitation does not make sense to me, and also > doesn't seem to help with the problem at hand, AFAICT. The "antlib:" URI > scheme has one main feature IIUC, namely the autodiscovery of antlibs > based on the package name. This feature is orthogonal to the namespace > URIs used for antlibs manually defined using <typedef>. > > All namespace URIs not actually mapped to an antlib, either by the > "antlib:" scheme or by an explicit <typedef>, should be ignored This is difficult as the the uri attribute of a typedef is handled at run-time and ns handling is done at parse time, hence my initial rule. > (or > handled as text -- not sure what the current implementation does). The current implementation will whine. Peter > That > decision should not involve the actual value of the namespace URI though. > > > We could modify namespace processing to ignore attributes not in the > > "right" namespace. > > See above. > > -chris --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
