+1 (non-binding) On Sat, 12 Aug 2023, 23:06 Jarek Potiuk, <ja...@potiuk.com> wrote:
> Hello everyone, > > I would like to raise a vote about modifying the result of vote from > https://lists.apache.org/thread/4dkbwob1wyl3xjbqdsmbd1mvgzflzp1f. and > RESTORE dagrun.conf UI option for triggering DAGs in 2.7.0 (which means > preparing RC2). > > I am writing that in the name of the release-management "concilium": > Ephraim, Hussein, Elad, Jens, Pankaj Koti, Rahul Vats, myself > > We discussed it today at the #release-management channel about the problem > with dagrun.conf functionality removal from 2.7.0 "Trigger UI". > https://apache-airflow.slack.com/archives/C03G9H97MM2/p1691833923538419 . > It's been also raised as concern by Hussein in the original PR and the > [VOTE] thread for 2.7.0rc1 > https://lists.apache.org/thread/pc89dh43kmpj267rpospo1lk5j3j6qkl . > > I think we all unanimously agree that removal of that functionality is > practically breaking change for many of our users, who will have no choice > but to modify their DAGs and add param definitions to their DAGs if they > want to continue triggering their DAGs via UI. > > While it is a good thing to do and this was the original intention, > to "push" our users in this direction, we realised that we do not give the > users a viable alternative and that effort required to rewrite their DAGs > might be far too much and might be a huge blocker to 2.7 adoption. The > "push" seems to be rather brutal and forceful, not a gentle one. > > We did not realise this consequence when we - as a community - ran the > previous vote, but we now think releasing 2.7.0 without this option will > cause a lot of problems. > > Since we all share such a unanimous view, we propose (and Ephraim is going > to do so) cancel RC1 and Jens already has PRs that should restore the > functionality. PR is shortly coming. > > However, that requires modifying the results of the previous vote. > > Consider that my binding +1 vote. > > We want to accelerate the voting a bit and we also propose to produce an > RC2 with the option restored to accelerate the process and not to delay the > 2.7.0 release too much. I propose this vote to last till 10 am Tuesday 26th > CEST - that should give enough time for everyone including the weekend > time. > > J. >
