2013/12/8 Robert Kaiser <ka...@kairo.at>: > I personally have not yet seen any arguments that would really apply for > making things different between mobile and desktop in your discussion, and I > think we should not make functionality different between form factors or > products when there is no good reason to make them different. > IMHO, what's named "Firefox" should work the same everywhere unless there is > a really good reason why a different variant should behave differently (and > there surely are often good reasons, but I haven't noticed those in this > discussion yet - nobody says I won't often use my laptop in public or my > mobile devices in private).
Ideally, I agree that what's named "Firefox" should work the same everywhere. Though, There are some difference between "desktop" and "mobile" for general usecases. Mobile including tablet would be more used in public space than desktop. I don't say laptops are never used in public space. Of course, some people use their laptop in very crowded train like which runs in Tokyo. Other some people use their mobile devices in only private. But they are limitless. I think that we need to discuss it based on general usecases at first. On that basis, we should discuss how we bypass or resolve some problems. 2013/12/8 Robert Kaiser <ka...@kairo.at>: > Tetsuharu OHZEKI schrieb: > >> I propose that we should disable "autoplay" feature of >> HTMLMediaElement on mobile. > > > I personally have not yet seen any arguments that would really apply for > making things different between mobile and desktop in your discussion, and I > think we should not make functionality different between form factors or > products when there is no good reason to make them different. > IMHO, what's named "Firefox" should work the same everywhere unless there is > a really good reason why a different variant should behave differently (and > there surely are often good reasons, but I haven't noticed those in this > discussion yet - nobody says I won't often use my laptop in public or my > mobile devices in private). > > That said, I think we should think about how we can enable more user control > of such features. If I open media tabs in the background, I probably don't > want them to autoplay at all. And then, there are situations on all my > devices where I may want autoplay and situations where I may not. How could > we give the user control over autoplay in an intuitive and easy way? Is > there a good way to do that on mobile form factors as well? > > KaiRo > _______________________________________________ > dev-platform mailing list > dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org > https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform -- Tetsuharu OHZEKI saneyuki.s.s...@gmail.com _______________________________________________ dev-platform mailing list dev-platform@lists.mozilla.org https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-platform
