Hi, most of the points I raised have been addressed by Auréliens POC, but there were some questions:
On 11/7/19 11:50 PM, Laura Arjona Reina wrote: > El 7 de noviembre de 2019 20:21:03 CET, Birger Schacht > <bir...@rantanplan.org> escribió: >> * Some even minor thoughts: >> + Both columns have the same icon and title for the 'More...' link- >> maybe the OS column 'More...' link should be titled 'Further infos' >> (and >> then the 'Further' from the link description should probably be >> dropped) >> and the 'More...' link on the community side could have another icon. > > Both 'More' link to the same page (different sections). Maybe we can remove > the "More" word in both columns and make the link with the following > sentence? I'm also fine with the current status, don't see a big problem with > the word and the icon repeated. Hm, I think using the subtitle as links would make the colums stand out because its a lot more text. Lets just leave it as it is for now. >> + I think the RSS links don't fit in the design of the page, both >> because the orange doesn't blend in with the rest of the colors of the >> page and also because they are the only elements on the page that are >> right-justified. I think its also too much distance from the elements >> they are referring to. Also both RSS icons have different designs (blue >> on orange vs. white on orange). > > Yes, I just pasted the code from the current homepage and didn't adjust the > layout... I would propose to use the 'rss' icon or glyph (the symbol). I'm > not sure where to place them, though (just after the last word in their > lines? Right-justified? In other place in the page?) In case of the security updates, I would put the RSS icon only on the page where the actual news items are (its already there). In case of the project news I would put the RSS icon on the right of the 'All the news' link. > >> + Is the 'Last modified' and 'Last Built' information used that often, >> that is should be in the footer or is it maybe also enough to put it in >> the HTML source as a comment? > > It's been in the footer since always and people wrote to the list when the > info was not accurate for some bug or issue, so I think it's valuable that is > visible. Ah, oke. > My proposal would be to put both sentences in the same line so the footer is > thinner. Ack. > >> + I found myself wanting to click on 'The community' or 'The operating >> system' and the pictures below. Maybe they should lead somewhere? > > The photos in the "People" column have clickable buttons to go to the > next/previous. The Debian logo in the "Operating System" section includes the > Download button. The titles... maybe could link to their respective section > in the "More..." subpage, but I doubt that it's helpful. > > Maybe you want to click there because of the 'hover animation', and if we > remove the animation (because of the issues mentioned above) the "wanting to > click" would disappear? I realized that I tend to click on them after I disabled the animations - but maybe thats just me. >> + (I think the header should be replaced by the 'splash' element >> everywhere ;)) ) >> > > This I didn't understand. Currently, the proposal is: > Header in homepage: > * Debian logo + search > * links to blog + micronews + planet > * Line to show the breadcrumbs ( /) > * banner of current stable theme with "Debian, The Universal Operating > System" (note that this is not translatable, currently) > > Header in subpages: > * Debian logo + search > * links to blog + micronews + planet > * Line to show the breadcrumbs (e.g. / latest news ) > > Could you specify the change you propose? Adding the banner of current stable > theme to every page? Removing something? I would propose to implement it as Auréliens POC has implemented it- with the banner of the current stable theme being the background of the header cheers, Birger
