Package: www.debian.org
Severity: important

As pointed out in

  https://lists.debian.org/msgid-search/201603301121.25333.lisi.re...@gmail.com

, we may be giving links to download ISO images but we're not giving
*any* useful information about the checksums and signatures for those
images in pages like

  https://www.debian.org/releases/stable/debian-installer/

As we're trying to educate users to verify their downloads more, we
really need to do better here. For many (most?) people that page is
already a wall of text, so just adding more stuff there won't help.

>From other discussions with users in debian-user and elsewhere, I
think we actually have *too many* pages describing how to download
ISOs etc., and it's becoming a pain to keep up with them all and keep
them all updated in sync. It's very easy for people to find
outdated/misleading/confusing pages that put them off.

So, I'd like to suggest a new, much simplified strategy:

 * *Remove* the direct link on the front page to the multi-arch
   netinst I'd argue that we *don't* need a direct link on the front
   page, and it's a dis-service to users who may download it and then
   not know what to do to verify etc.

 * Replace that link with a link to a simple "Download" page which
   gives *simple* instructions and links. This would be similar to
   what we have at https://www.debian.org/distrib/ , but we also need
   to re-org that page and make it prettier and clearer, add some
   graphics etc.:

    Download Debian
    ===============

    Debian is [ ... ]

         GRAPHIC 1                          GRAPHIC 2
         (picture of installer)             (picture of desktop)
      * Download installer              * Download live image
        ==================                ===================
        + (link to m-a netinst?)          + link to favoured 64-bit image
        + link to 64-bit netinst          + link to favoured 32-bit image
        + link to 32-bit netinst
        + more... (link to page with     + more... (link to page with
          more architecture options,       more architecture options,
          download options, etc.)          download options, etc.)

                                  (CENTERED, in a box?)
                       GRAPHIC 3
                       (picture of checksums / padlock etc.)
                      * Verify your download
                        ====================
                        (simple rationale and instructions,
                         link to page with more details)

        GRAPHIC 4                         GRAPHIC 5
        (picture of USB stick)            (picture of CD/DVD media)
      * How to write to USB             * How to write to optical media
        ===================               =============================
        (simple instructions,             (simple instructions,
         link to pages with more           link to pages with more
         details)                          details)

 * Re-organise all the other pages to act as the subsidiary pages
   mentioned here, removing the redundancy that's biting us and
   hurting users.

Thoughts?

-- 
Steve McIntyre, Cambridge, UK.                                st...@einval.com
"... the premise [is] that privacy is about hiding a wrong. It's not.
 Privacy is an inherent human right, and a requirement for maintaining
 the human condition with dignity and respect."
  -- Bruce Schneier

Reply via email to