A wishlist bug report against the debian installer pseudo package would seem to be an appropriate way to go.

I would also like to see nbd support in the installer.  I'm guessing it will be too late for bookworm, I tried that using the nightly installer and had a similar problem - nbd kernel module was available but no userspace tools.

https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/pkgreport.cgi?pkg=d-i.debian.org;dist=unstable

Thanks,
Alex

On 21/05/23 06:17, Tomasz Wolak wrote:
On 5/20/23 19:49, Tomasz Wolak wrote:

On 5/20/23 19:17, Stefan Monnier wrote:
I will not go to further details here, anyone interested can go to:
https://t-w.github.io/debian/2022/03/09/diskless_debian_11_pxe_nbd/
for details.

Have you reported a bug about this?

You might also get in touch with the maintainer of `nbd-client-udeb`
since that package seems designed for your use case, so if it doesn't
work well enough, they might like to know.


Well, it is not a problem with nbd-client-udeb, it is a problem with the lack of it in Debian installer. And I am not quite sure if this is a bug or just an unimplemented functionality. Debian installer do not have a fully-fledged interface for configuring NBD, so this might be avoided for a reason, like not giving people something that might/does not work.

My point is that I would like that it progressed a bit further so that, at least, using the console of the installation system, nbd device could be configured and used. The pieces I did proves that it does not require much (esp. that my changes could be just used to improve at least initrd in this matter; only adding nbd-client to the installer remains).

So, I am not sure if reporting a bug is a right place. There is no particular package that I can point to...


But contacting the maintainer of the nbd-client seems to be a good idea. I will do that. Thanks.

Reply via email to