Quoth Jonathan Wilson:
> On Thursday 17 January 2008 10:48:41 Johannes Wiedersich wrote:
> > I encountered something rather odd and in my eyes disturbing: if I edit
> > a symlinked file with an ordinary editor (nano, kate, ...) the editor
> > edits the file instead and leaves the symlink intact.
> 
> I Tried this on SuSE and it behaves the same. If it's a bug (sure seems odd 
> to 
> me) it must be in the upstream sed, not Debian's packages.

I don't think it's a bug, but a feature. And a workaround is quite easy to
implement, if you need it (via file or ls -l and a small sed script or whatever
alternative there might be in UNIX-world). Though it might be confusing to the
beginner, when I point sed to a _filename_ I want the resulting file to be
written to *that* file - that's surely not what everyone wants, but at least it
dodges semantic ambiguity and makes things more predictable.

As I said, circumventing this isn't really much of an issue, so that shouldn't
really pose any problems.

Aleks

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Reply via email to