"Richard" == Richard Otte <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
Richard> It was not like this in /etc/exim/exim.conf, where I had:
Richard> qualify_domain = otte.ucsc.edu local_domains =
Richard> localhost:otte.ucsc.edu (I suspect the .conf~ file is a
Richard> backup that didn't get removed). So I removed
Richard> /etc/exim.conf~,and restarted the machine.
Richard,
I think your local_domains should be "localhost:otte:otte.ucsc.edu"
(though I'm not an exim expert by any means). I'm saying this because
you seem to get mail at this machine addresses as ric@localhost,
ric@otte, and [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>> 2002-11-08 08:47:06 18ACHh-0000Gb-00 <= [EMAIL PROTECTED] H=otte (localhost)
>> [127.0.0.1] P=esmtp S=1214 id=20021108164942.GE262@perelandra
>> 2002-11-08 08:47:06 18ACHh-0000Gb-00 => ric@otte R=smarthost T=remote_smtp
>> H=smtp.ucsc.edu [128.114.129.35]
>> 2002-11-08 08:47:06 18ACHh-0000Gb-00 Completed
This is the key part. Your mail is being delivered to ric@otte, and
I'm guessing this is fetchmail. But "otte" is not a local domain, so
it is being sent to your smart host. My question would be: where
exactly did you ask fetcmail to drop your mail (what is on the line
ending with "is xxx here")?
>> 2002-11-08 08:47:16 18ACHs-0000Gi-00 <= [EMAIL PROTECTED] H=cats-mx2.ucsc.edu
>> (ucsc.edu) [128.114.129.35] P=esmtp S=1628 id=20021108164942.GE262@perelandra
>> 2002-11-08 08:47:16 18ACHs-0000Gi-00 => ric <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> D=procmail
>> T=procmail_pipe
>> 2002-11-08 08:47:16 18ACHs-0000Gi-00 Completed
And now your smart host is sending it back to you directly (no
fetchmail) at [EMAIL PROTECTED], which exim now recognizes as being
"here" since it matches local_domains.
Richard> I then fetched the exact same message from my home
Richard> machine (which works fine) and noticed the log file deals
Richard> with the message once:
Richard> 2002-11-08 09:13:29 18AChF-0000eM-00 Completed 2002-11-08
Richard> 09:13:29 18AChF-0000eM-01 <= [EMAIL PROTECTED] H=perelandra
Richard> (localhost) [127.0.0.1] P=esmtp S=1237
Richard> id=20021108164942.GE262@perelandra
Richard> 2002-11-08 09:13:29 18AChF-0000eM-01 => ric
Richard> <ric@localhost> D=procmail T=procmail_pipe 2002-11-08
Richard> 09:13:29 18AChF-0000eM-01 Completed
Richard> This puzzles me, because the exim.conf files are almost
Richard> identical; the differences are in the localhost names.
Puzzles me too. Perhaps you fetchmailrc script delivers to different
addresses? When you say the differences are in localhost names, can
you precisely point to which entries in exim.conf are different?
Richard> Furthermore, both of these machines have the same
Richard> .forward file, which reads: |/usr/bin/procmail -t and
Richard> .fetchmailrc is the same for both.
Incidentally, you do not need the .forward file. The way exim is
configured it would process the .procmailrc file anyway. The extra
.forward file probably does nothing here but confuse the issue a
little bit ;-)
Richard> So I don't know why my home machine gets the message and
Richard> sends it to ric <ric@localhost> and my office machine
Richard> sends it to ric@otte. I can understand why it would have
Richard> done that with the old exim.conf~ file (with qualify
Richard> domain=otte), but now that I've removed that, shouldn't
Richard> it use /etc/exim/exim.conf where it is listed as (qualify
Richard> domain=otte.ucsc.edu)?
Yes. It really should, unless fetchmail is qualifying the name to
start with.
Richard> I may have misspoken when I said it worked fine when I
Richard> took out the procmailrc. What I noticed was that a
Richard> couple of messages didn't have the long delay; but that
Richard> may have been a quirk, and they may still have been
Richard> processed twice. I'm going into my office in a while,
Richard> and I will experiment some more with this. If anyone has
Richard> any suggestions on things to try, I'm open.
That was probably because your campus mail exchanger worked really
quickly some of the time, and at other times it took a while.
Good luck.
/Shyamal
--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
