# Bcc: control tags 459333 + patch thanks On 08/01/05 17:00 +0100, Pierre Habouzit said ... > > On Sat, Jan 05, 2008 at 01:50:56PM +0000, Joerg Jaspert wrote: > > > > With the current title you request removal from unstable, please fix. > > Rrriiight, it'd be nice if reportbug could have the proper questions, > I never remember what the subject for RMs should be, and usually > maintainers don't ask for removals _that_ often, so it'd be best if > reportbug assumed we were stupid about that :) > > To the reporbug maintainer: it'd be great if when reporting a bug to > ftp.debian.org a `removal` bug suite of questions could happen that > would ask for the targetted suites (defaulting to unstable), the reason > (RoM, RoQA, RoRM, ..) and ask for the complementar informations > (obsolete, no upstream, whatever).
Attached patch attempts to reduce this pain. Comments are welcome. TV indicated that he would sponsor an NMU if (among other bugs) it has this bug fixed. Giridhar -- Y Giridhar Appaji Nag | http://www.appaji.net/
diff -Nur reportbug-3.39.orig/debianbts.py reportbug-3.39/debianbts.py
--- reportbug-3.39.orig/debianbts.py 2007-04-20 02:03:09.000000000 +0530
+++ reportbug-3.39/debianbts.py 2008-03-19 01:11:14.000000000 +0530
@@ -155,7 +155,7 @@
'cdrom' : 'Problems with installation from CD-ROMs',
# dpkg-iwj -- The dpkg branch maintained by Ian Jackson
'debian-policy' : 'Proposed changes in the Debian policy documentation',
- 'ftp.debian.org' : 'Problems with the FTP site',
+ 'ftp.debian.org' : 'Problems with the FTP site and Package removal requests',
'general' : 'General problems (e.g., that many manpages are mode 755)',
# 'install' : 'Problems with the sarge installer.',
# 'installation' : 'General installation problems not covered otherwise.',
@@ -182,6 +182,115 @@
'debian-general' : 'Any non-package-specific bug',
}
+def handle_debian_ftp(package, bts, ui, fromaddr, online=True, http_proxy=None):
+ body = reason = archs = ''
+ suite = 'unstable'
+ headers = []
+ pseudos = []
+ query = True
+
+ tag = ui.menu('What sort of request is this? (If none of these '
+ 'things mean anything to you, or you are trying to report '
+ 'a bug in an existing package, please press Enter to '
+ 'exit reportbug.)', {
+ 'ROM' :
+ "Package removal - Request Of Maintainer.",
+ 'RoQA' :
+ "Package removal - Requested by the QA team.",
+ 'ROP' :
+ "Package removal - Request of Porter.",
+ 'ROSRM' :
+ "Package removal - Request of Stable Release Manager.",
+ 'NBS' :
+ "Package removal - Not Built [by] Source.",
+ 'NPOASR' :
+ "Package removal - Never Part Of A Stable Release.",
+ 'NVIU' :
+ "Package removal - Newer Version In Unstable.",
+ 'ANAIS' :
+ "Package removal - Architecture Not Allowed In Source.",
+ 'ICE' :
+ "Package removal - Internal Compiler Error.",
+ '[cruft-report]' :
+ "Package removal - detected by the cruft finder script.",
+ 'other' :
+ "Not a package removal request, report other problems.",
+ }, 'Choose the request type: ', empty_ok=True)
+ if not tag:
+ ui.long_message('To report a bug in a package, use the name of the package, not ftp.debian.org.\n')
+ raise SystemExit
+
+ severity = 'normal'
+ if tag == 'other':
+ return
+ else:
+ prompt = 'Please enter the name of the package: '
+ package = ui.get_string(prompt)
+ if not package:
+ ui.ewrite('You seem to want to report a generic bug, not request a removal\n')
+ return
+
+ ui.ewrite('Checking status database...\n')
+ info = reportbug.get_package_status(package)
+ available = info[1]
+
+ query = False
+ if not available:
+ info = reportbug.get_source_package(package)
+ if info:
+ info = reportbug.get_package_status(info[0][0])
+
+ if not info:
+ cont = ui.select_options(
+ "This package doesn't appear to exist; continue?",
+ 'yN', {'y': 'Ignore this problem and continue.',
+ 'n': 'Exit without filing a report.' })
+ if cont == 'n':
+ sys.exit(1)
+ else:
+ package = info[12] or package
+
+ suite = ui.menu('Is the removal to be done in a suite other than'
+ ' "unstable"? Please press Enter for "unstable"', {
+ 'oldstable' : "Old stable.",
+ 'oldstable-proposed-updates' : "Old stable proposed updates.",
+ 'stable' : "Stable.",
+ 'stable-proposed-updates' : "Stable proposed updates.",
+ 'testing' : "Testing",
+ 'testing-proposed-updates' : "Testing proposed updates",
+ 'experimental' : "Experimental.",
+ }, 'Choose the suite: ', empty_ok=True)
+ if not suite:
+ suite = 'unstable'
+
+ why = 'Please enter the reason for removal: '
+ reason = ui.get_string(why)
+ if not reason: return
+
+ partial = ui.select_options(
+ "Is this removal request for specific architectures?",
+ 'yN', {'y': 'This is a partial (specific architectures) removal.',
+ 'n': 'This removal is for all architectures.' })
+ if partial == 'y':
+ prompt = 'Please enter the arch list separated by a space: '
+ archs = ui.get_string(prompt)
+ if not archs:
+ ui.long_message('Partial removal requests must have a list of architectures.\n')
+ raise SystemExit
+
+ if archs:
+ if suite != 'unstable':
+ subject = 'RM: %s/%s [%s] -- %s; %s' % (package, suite, archs, tag, reason)
+ else:
+ subject = 'RM: %s [%s] -- %s; %s' % (package, archs, tag, reason)
+ else:
+ if suite != 'unstable':
+ subject = 'RM: %s/%s -- %s; %s' % (package, suite, tag, reason)
+ else:
+ subject = 'RM: %s -- %s; %s' % (package, tag, reason)
+
+ return (subject, severity, headers, pseudos, body, query)
+
def handle_wnpp(package, bts, ui, fromaddr, online=True, http_proxy=None):
desc = body = ''
headers = []
@@ -310,7 +419,9 @@
'btsroot' : 'http://www.debian.org/Bugs/',
'otherpkgs' : debother,
'nonvirtual' : ['linux-image', 'kernel-image'],
- 'specials' : { 'wnpp': handle_wnpp },
+ 'specials' :
+ { 'wnpp': handle_wnpp,
+ 'ftp.debian.org': handle_debian_ftp },
# Dependency packages
'deppkgs' : ('gcc', 'g++', 'cpp', 'gcj', 'gpc', 'gobjc',
'chill', 'gij', 'g77', 'python', 'python-base',
diff -Nur reportbug-3.39.orig/reportbug reportbug-3.39/reportbug
--- reportbug-3.39.orig/reportbug 2007-08-17 04:10:37.000000000 +0530
+++ reportbug-3.39/reportbug 2008-03-18 23:48:52.000000000 +0530
@@ -344,6 +344,14 @@
False):
return get_package_name(bts, mode)
+ if package == 'ftp.debian.org':
+ if not ui.yes_no(
+ 'Are you sure you want to file a bug on ftp.debian.org?',
+ 'Yes, I am a developer or know what I\'m doing.',
+ 'No, I am not a developer and I don\'t know what ftp.debian.org is.',
+ False):
+ return get_package_name(bts, mode)
+
return package
def special_prompts(package, bts, ui, fromaddr):
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature
