Niels Thykier:
> Hi,
> 
> I have a quick review of the RC bugs in *key* packages that are unfixed
> in unstable according to UDD.  The following is a list of 32 of these
> (out of about 180) with proposed verdicts/tagging to start a debate
> about them.
> 

Thanks for the feedback.

The outcome is below:

> 
> [...]
> The list:
> 
>> Bug          Source                  Verdict         Title
>> [Tagged]     804272  akonadi                 can-defer       fails to 
>> synchronize caldav to OpenXChange without notice
>> [Tagged]     850874  ark                     can-defer       ark: 
>> CVE-2017-5330: Unintended execution of scripts and executable files
>> [Fixed]      827744  bzip2                   can-defer       bzip2: 
>> CVE-2016-3189: heap use after free in bzip2recover
>> [Tagged]     834845  chicken                 can-defer       chicken: 
>> CVE-2016-6830 CVE-2016-6831
>> [Downgrade]  848976  courier-authlib         will-remove     Unsuitable to 
>> be part of stable release without proper maintainer
>> [Downgrade]  848977  courier-unicode         will-remove     Unsuitable to 
>> be part of stable release without proper maintainer
>> [Tagged]     827297  deborphan               can-defer       deborphan: No 
>> support for versioned provides
>> [Changed]    851819  flashplugin-nonfree     can-defer       ERROR: wget 
>> failed to download http://people.debian.org/~bartm/...
>> [Tagged]     814978  gcc-5                   will-remove     gcc-5: gnat 
>> paths are wrong due to ada-gcc-name.diff
>> [Tagged]     848220  gcc-5                   will-remove     gcc-5 should 
>> not ship in stretch
>> [Removed]    835960  gcc-5-cross             will-remove     gcc-5-cross: 
>> non-standard gcc/g++ used for build (gcc-5)
>> [Removed]    835777  gcc-5-cross             will-remove     gcc-5-cross: 
>> FTBFS: patch fails to apply
>> [Removed]    835692  gcc-5-cross-ports       will-remove     
>> gcc-5-cross-ports: FTBFS: patches fail to apply
>> [Removed]    835961  gcc-5-cross-ports       will-remove     
>> gcc-5-cross-ports: non-standard gcc/g++ used for build (gcc-5)
>> [Tagged]     852891  lintian                 is-blocker      lintian: FTBFS: 
>> Test failures
>> [Fixed]      850216  mariadb-10.1            is-blocker      
>> mysql-server-5.6: Listens on * by default after installation (related to use 
>> of alternatives)
>> [Removed]    805828  mysql-5.6               will-remove     
>> mysql-server-5.6: upgrade didn't work, package unusable, mysql does not start
>> [Removed]    798080  mysql-5.6               will-remove     
>> mysql-server-5.6: service stop hangs forever on systemd
>> [Removed]    804920  mysql-5.6               will-remove     
>> mysql-server-5.6: needs Conflicts: cqrlog (<< 1.9.0-5~)
>> [Removed]    837615  mysql-5.6               will-remove     mysql-5.6: 
>> don't include in stretch
>> [Removed]    812812  mysql-5.6               will-remove     MySQL client 
>> library should ship a symbols file, or at least not have a Lintian override 
>> to hide the problem
>> [Fixed]      851770  php-gettext             can-defer       php-gettext: 
>> CVE-2015-8980
>> [Tagged]     851771  php-gettext             can-defer       php-gettext: 
>> CVE-2016-6175
>> [Tagged]     852163  python3.5               is-blocker      
>> python3.5-minimal wont configure
>> [Tagged]     820381  rar                     will-remove     rar crashes.
>> [Fixed]      852883  systemd                 is-blocker      systemd: FTBFS: 
>> Test failures
>> [Tagged]     757083  sysvinit                is-blocker      initscripts: 
>> please treat /usr (if separate) the same as /
>> [Downgrade]  851446  sysvinit                is-blocker      mkdir: cannot 
>> create directory `/run/shm': File exists
>> [Removed]    852603  virglrenderer           can-defer       virglrenderer: 
>> CVE-2016-10163
>> [Removed]    852604  virglrenderer           can-defer       virglrenderer: 
>> CVE-2017-5580
>> [Fixed]      845793  zlib                    is-blocker      lib64z1-dev 
>> doesn't provide a shlibs file, causing package build failures
>> [Fixed]      787956  zlib                    is-blocker      lib32z1-dev: 
>> Compiling anything that includes <zlib.h> with -m32 fails
> 

Legend:
 * [Tagged]    => Tagged with the given tag
 * [Changed]   => Tagged with a different tag than originally proposed
                  (flashplugin-nonfree, will-remove => can-defer)
 * [Removed]   => Package was removed from testing
 * [Downgrade] => The bug was downgraded to non-RC (by someone else)
 * [Fixed]     => The bug was fixed and migrated to testing.


RC bug count:
    32 intial

   - 6 being fixed
   - 3 downgrades
   -11 from removals
   - 5 tagged ignore
 -----------------
    12 remaining

These are split into
     6 tagged can-defer (ignored)
     3 tagged will-remove
     3 tagged is-blocker

Thanks for the assistance,
~Niels


Reply via email to