> However, on a new news item, all news will shift one place, and the most
> recent one will be called '1.html'. This makes linking to items quite
> impossible, you think you're linking somewhere, but it changes
> afterwards.

Apart from linking to those pages, there are also a problem more related
to the PTS itself. Today I experienced the following bug: I looked at
the PTS overview of a package yesterday and watched the topmost
newsitem. Last night a new version of the package was uploaded and when
clicking the top news item I got the changes from the previous version.
What happened was that my browser cached that page. This would have been
prevented if the link for a specific newsitem would have been constant.

One can also imagine a race condition, because HTTP is stateless. One
could have the overview page open, meanwhile a new upload is done, and
sometime after the upload one clicks a newsitem. One will get another
item because all will have shifted. With more static naming I would have
gotten the item I requested.

I'm willing to fix this sometime if someone can point me to the sources
of the PTS.


Regards,

Thijs

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature

Reply via email to