Hi Santiago,

I agree with you that key endorsements should be better documented. In fact, I 
had issues myself understanding the requirements/process as key endorsements 
are not even mentioned in https://wiki.debian.org/DebianMaintainer.

Other than with werdahias, to which I am exceedingly grateful for accepting to 
be my advocate, I have worked with other DDs during the last months, so I hope 
I'll be able to obtain at least one other key endorsement. As for the trust 
placed in my key, could you please let me know if you would consider what 
follows to satisfy the trust requirements, especially since you say that the 
endorsements must be strong ones and since I need to ask another DD? Of course, 
I am fully aware that it's ultimately DDs that must testify for these 
requirements, so please interpret my question as only aimed at better 
understanding the process, and what I may or may not ask, for lack of 
documentation.

The key with fingerprint 50CF C9D5 E5BD E1CB CA57  FD7B 6DF0 08E7 0F28 CBF7 is 
the one I'm currently using on Salsa. My email address, from which I'm writing 
and which I use for all projects I'm involved in, is verified on Salsa. My 
first contribution on Salsa [1] dates back to May 26th and was reviewed by 
werdahias and others (werdahias wrote two months in the key endorsement 
message, but to this date it's actually exactly four). However, I did not start 
signing commits before I decided I wanted to become DM (a couple of months 
ago). Even then, I first started using an older RSA key I was using for other 
stuff, and then replaced it with a brand new ECC key, which I've now been using 
for around one month to sign my commits, and is the one with the fingerprint 
reported above (endorsed by werdahias after receiving proof that I own both 
keys). Both the keys are registered in Salsa, and the first key is signed by 
the second one to keep track of the link. I could of course also sign the 
second with the first if needed. In Salsa I've been a member of the Rust Team 
for exactly two months (albeit contributing for longer from outside) and I 
count ~ 100 contributions to debcargo-conf alone, plus many others to the 
non-rust components of the Asahi ecosystem packaged in Debian. Not all of these 
are signed, but a large majority of them is since early August at least, and 
they are linked to an account with a fairly longer contribution history, as 
noted above.

Given the above, would an endorsement from two DDs attesting this kind of link 
between key and contributions be considered strong enough for consideration as 
DM?

Best,

NC

Reply via email to