[please cc me as I'm not on the list]
Hi Chris,
On Thu, May 13, 2010 at 06:02:11PM +0300, Nanakos Chrysostomos wrote [edited]:
> P.S: I had already increased the version in Build-Depends for debhelper
Not in the version I reviewed :)
> ( debhelper >> 5.0.0)
``>>x'' means strictly higher than x, whereas you want ``>=x'' (at least x);
see policy 7.1
OK here's a few more remarks (some of which I should have mentioned in my
first email).
debian/changelog:
* Added ${misc:Depends} to rules file. --> ``... to debian/control file''
* Updated debian/compat to version 5.
* Changed debhleper version to control file so to correspond
the new changes.
-->
The latter is quite ambiguous. How about:
* Bumped debhelper versioned Build-Depends to 5, and updated debian/compat
debian/copyright:
``it is currently maintained by Chris...'' should be part of the very first
sentence that talks about the debianisation; where it's now gives the
impression that you are the *upstream* maintainer!
please revise the file to be more like the example given in the New
Maintainer's Guide, section 4.2 (pay attention to headers, indentation and
using © instead of (c))
debian/dirs:
debian/dirs lists usr/sbin even though the package puts nothing under
/usr/sbin. You could have found that out with lintian :)
Finally, please extract all changes to upstream files to patches (eg. with
quilt; see http://wiki.debian.org/UsingQuilt):
$ lsdiff -z ../morse_2.1-4.diff.gz | grep -v '\/debian\/'
morse-2.1/Makefile
morse-2.1/morseX11.1
morse-2.1/morse.d/Makefile
morse-2.1/morse.d/morse.c
morse-2.1/qso.d/QSO.c
morse-2.1/qso.d/grammar.c
You'll know you've done all that's required once the above command's output is
empty. It is important that debian-originated changes are explicitly
identified (and can thus be more easily shared, eg. via patch-tracking.d.o)
Cheers,
Serafeim
--
debtags-organised WNPP bugs: http://members.hellug.gr/serzan/wnpp
--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-mentors-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org
Archive: http://lists.debian.org/20100513171003.gh2...@mobee
