Kern Sibbald <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > ===== > Exception to the GPL: > Linking: > Bacula may be linked and distributed with any libraries permitted > under the GPL, or with any non-GPLed libraries, including OpenSSL, > that are required for its proper functioning, providing the license > and hence source code of those non-GPLed libraries comply with the > Open Source Definition as defined by the Open Source Initiative > (www.opensource.org). > ======= > > I think this is much clearer than my original license
I see several areas that are unclear. "any libraries permitted under the GPL" — the GPL doesn't "permit libraries", the GPL permits actions normally reserved under copyright law. As for which license terms the GPL allows for distributed derived works, that's "the terms of this license" i.e. the GPL itself. "or with any non-GPLed libraries ... that are required for its proper functioning" — anyone could modify the work so that it depends on some library and then claim that library is "required for its proper functioning", so this clause is effectively null. "the Open Source Definition as defined by the Open Source Initiative" — at what point in time? At the time this clause was written? At the time I received the work? At any time someone reads this text? It's far clearer to simply give the exact set of extra terms you consider acceptable, rather than delegating it to a website subject to change after you write this clause. > avoids allowing someone to modify the license All they need to do is convince the OSI to certify their license terms (which is far from a guarantee the license terms are free), and then those license terms are retroactively allowed under this clause. > but is a bit broader than the OpenSSL exception listed above I'd argue, based on the above, it's rather overbroad. > but corresponds to what I believed the GPL permitted when I > originally chose the license for releasing the code. I don't see how you draw this conclusion. The GPL makes clear what terms are permitted for derived works: "the terms of this license". -- \ "The World is not dangerous because of those who do harm but | `\ because of those who look at it without doing anything." | _o__) —Albert Einstein | Ben Finney -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
