-qa crosspost removed > 1) It seems that only two people can comment on an entry. If I see a > problem that two other people have missed, I can't point it out. Agreed. I'm going to add a freetext field in the packages detail page for additional comments and a flag on the list page indicating whether more comments are available.
> 2) It looks like I can edit other people's observations, possibly by > accident (by hitting submit after them). Fix (1) and this should go > away, too. I didn't actually want to bother setting up a real rights system, and I think we can trust the few people that will help not to be abusive. As for the accident, yes, that's a possible risk, the best solution is to carefully coordinate the work through the wiki. I don't expect dozens of people anyway :) I also added a few safeguards: reviewers must be different, you can't fill review2 if review1 isn't filled. > 3) It doesn't look like there is a way to comment on the "current > proposal", only on the original description (and only for two people; > see above). Ok, I'll add that > 4) I notice tags are part of the description shown. Do you intend to > review the tags as well? This should be clarified on the wiki. If the > answer is "yes", a link to tags documentation needs to be added. This was actually a side effect of the filling script. I had thought it might be a good idea to review tags at the same time, but I think it's too early for a tags review. The maintainers haven't had a chance to tag their packages themselves. > 5) The things to look for needs some work. For example, it needs > something like "description fails to show how the package fits in with > related pacakges" (e.g., foo-pgsql vs. foo-mysql. Or many others) Fixed, feel free to edit. > PS: Having "Improper english" as a thing to look out for on the Wiki > page was rather bad looking. Fixed. Same with the incomplete list at the > top. Hehe, that's why I said native english speakers would be greatly appreciated and why several people should review the texts. Thanks for your feedback, -- Clément -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
