Gerfried Fuchs <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
> * Brian May <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [2002-08-29 09:50]:
> > On Tue, Aug 27, 2002 at 08:48:31AM +0200, Gerfried Fuchs wrote:
> >> What we need is a change here: Bugs should just be closed in unstable.
> >> How to do this? They should be rather be tagged <sarge> than be closed
> >> by an upload to unstable. Not unconditionally, of course. The version
> ^^^^^^^^^^^
> >> of the bugreport should be compared with the version currently in
> ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
> >> testing. Some sort of algorithm not too complex but able to handle most
> ^^^^^^^^
> >> of the cases shouldn't be too hard to do (yes, I volunteer to help
> >> there).
> >
> > Then bugs will me marked as sarge, even though they might be bugs
> > specific to unstable.
>
> Just to make sure you didn't miss that I thought of that problem
> already, thanks. Or do you think of that the bugs are there because of
> other packages in unstable? Well, then the bug might be filed against
> the wrong package. Which would leave us with a problem -- the version
> is rather meta information in the bugreport and not real useful data, is
> it? So currently there is no need to change the version field if a bug
> gets reassigned to a different package... *hmmm* Difficult issue, but
> still no issue that shouldn't be raised/thought about.
What about the folowing mechanism:
- The dist of the reportie(s) is checked. If its not in the bugreport
guess stable.
- When a "closes" is seen in the changelog the version of the
uploaded package is noted.
- Reporties using unstable get the normal mail as it is now.
- Reporties with testing get a mail that a bugfix is uploaded to
unstable and they might want to try that out. Once the package closing
the bug (or any later version) moves to testing they get a mail
seaying that the bug is fixed in testing.
- same for stable but 3 mails. A "is in unstable", a "is in testing"
and a "is closed" mail.
- The BTS tags bugs as [closed unstable], [closed testing] or
[closed] respectivly. The script moving things to testing and stable
tells the BTS about the version it moves and the BTS changes the tags
according to a version compare.
- Bugs with tag [sid] could get closed immediatly with a upload to
sid. The [sid] or [sarge] tags could be adjusted by the BTS when a
new version is moved. If bar is moved from sid to sarge all [sid]
tags become [sid][sarge]. A [closed unstable] would replace the
[sid] tag but leave the [sarge] tag.
MfG
Goswin
