reopen 346354
thanks

Please Cc: bug submitters when discussing matters with them.  The BTS
does not do this automatically.

> upstream is providing the html files under the GPL. They are not 
> providing the files the html is generated from, but since they are the 
> copyright owners, they are free to release the files in any format they 
> like (and any license they like).
> 
> So regarding the maxdb-doc package, there is no violation of the GPL 
> because upstream has chosen to release the html files under this license 
> (and nothing more).

Sure, it's not a GPL violation by upstream.  But the GPL requires that
Debian provides the source code corresponding to the generated HTML
files.  If we can't do so, the documentation is not redistributable
and cannot be distributed by Debian.

You should ask upstream to provide the source code, or to use a
DFSG-compliant non-copyleft license (like the BSD license).


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to