Package: setmixer
Version: 27DEC94ds1-1
Severity: Wishlist

I have yet to find any sound mixer application that can properly control
all my sound devices.  With setmixer conflicting with alsa-base and
aumix, I loose functionality.  Removing the functionality that saves and
restores mixer settings on boot-up and the resulting conflicts would be
a better solution than conflicting with similar programs and thereby
leaving Debian users with one less option.  Just because a program _can_
be run at system startup doesn't mean it _has_ to be.

I can have multiple types of web browsers and editors and all manner of
programs, why can't I have multiple types of mixers?

The result of the recent changes is that one more useful piece of
software - one more option - cannot be installed.  On the other hand, if
the initscripts and conflicts were removed, functionality would be
retained and I would still have all my options.  If someone wants to run
setmixer at boot, it's relatively easy to put a little script in
/etc/rc.boot. It's also reasonable to assume that someone wanting to use
an obscure commandline program like setmixer would be capable of doing
so.  An example startup script could even be placed in
/usr/share/doc/setmixer/examples.

Referencing bug # 202151, if the maintainer believes, "...looks like
aumix has improved since I uploaded setmixer, so  there is not much
specific need for setmixer anymore", he should probably give up the
program.


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to