-=| Joey Hess, Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 11:44:55AM -0400 |=-
> Salvatore Bonaccorso wrote:
> >   * The requirement for Perl modules to have a versioned Depend 
> >   and
> >     Build-Depend on perl >= 5.6.0-16 has been removed.        [perl]
> > 
> > So the fallback to the version (>= 5.6.0-16) should be possible to
> > drop in dh_perl.
> 
> It's certianly possible to drop.
> 
> I don't, however, know if there's any point in me dropping it.
> 
> (Especially as backporters may want to add it back in.)

As I see it, the versioned dependency only matters if one tries to 
install woody+ packages on potato. This is to be avoided because of 
the change in the directory structure in 5.6.0-16.

(historical info: potato has 5.004.05-2, woody has 5.6.1-8.9)

The difference between with or without the version would be 
uninstallable bakcage (with) vs. non-working package (without).

Though I admit uninstallable package is better than a not working one, 
does this mean we'd keep the dependency versioned forever? Potato is 
four releases behind the current stable already (potato woody sarge 
etch lenny). Even security updates were discontinued since July 2003 
:)

I hope this clarifies the reasoning behind Salvatore's proposal. It 
bascally means "we don't care about potato anymore", which is not far 
from the reality, I think.

-- 
dam

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Reply via email to