[LogFileMaxSize]

| > Yes, the behavior of 0 is explained there. The confusion arose, when
| > it was explicitly set. I waould have expected the manual page's
| > default value. Thus the question: "Why the defaul configuration uses
| > 0?"
|
| I have to think in terms of what is a sane
| default on first install, and then respect user changes to those defaults
| on upgrade.

Fair enough.

| The problem is that adding commented explanations for every file option
| and combination will create a huge maintenance nightmare, it would seem
| to me.  Again, I am willing to accept patches to make it happen.  But,
| I want to caution - this should be done for all directives, or none.
| A partial patch will just lead to more people asking for the same thing
| for other directives, and a piecework approach seems wrong.  If you want
| a heavily commented config file, choose no to debconf configuration,
| and take a look at the one in /usr/share/doc/clamav-base/examples/.

I would like to propose another solution.

- Add a comment to the beginning of clamd.conf to point people to read
  /usr/share/doc/README.DEbian for changes to variables that
  differ from the defaults outlined in the manual page / upstream.

- In /usr/share/doc/README.DEbian there would be section
  "clamd.conf changes to upstream" and list of only those variables,
  whose values have been changed accompanied with a brief reasoning
  why changes were made.
 
| > Other than that, I do not have expertise on how the upgrade works, or
| > how the confguration files are managed, so I'm unable to make better
| > suggestions.
| 
| I am not sure what to do.  I would like to close it outright, since I
| see this as a misunderstanding about the features of the debconf
| configuration, rather than a bug.  However, if you feel strongly enough
| about this issue to supply a patch, let me know.  I will in that case
| leave the bug open until the patch is merged in and uploaded.

A misunderstanding may be bug as well if the medium may not have
communicated the idea to the end user well enough :-)

Let me know if the above would work from maintenance point of view.
In any case I'm out of ideas, so you can close this bug. If I were
competent with the packaging I would have provided patches, but
as it is now, I cannot suggest anything creative for it.

Jari



-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to