[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Eugen Dedu writes:
Package: unison-gtk
Version: 2.13.16-6
Severity: normal
Hi,
I find very confusing the name of files in the diff window (when
pressing the diff button in the graphical environment unison-gtk).
What is the first file and what is the second? diff -u .../intro.tex
and .../intro.tex#unisondiff- say nothing about that.
I checked this and the 1st file is the local file, the 2nd is the
remote file. I would prefer the 1st one be the remote file and the
2nd one my own file, because the remote file is the "old" version,
isn't it?
So I propose:
- to put as 1st file the remote file
- to name the remote file something like this: .../intro.tex#remotefile
Thank you for taking into account this bug.
Well, i am not sure that the remote file is always the "old" file, and
i think that putting it 1st or 2nd doesn't really improve anything.
Concerning the naming convention, i think that the first filename
(.../intro.tex) should point to the fact that this is a local file...
Hi,
I agree with the order, because there are different uses of the program
("old" sometimes is local, sometimes is distant).
However, the names are not explicit.
Aa program must be as clear as possible. Without reading the
documentation, do you agree to lose 100€ if ../intro.tex is not the
local one and ../intro.tex#unisondiff- is not the distant one?
I think that "Remote file" for ex. is a much better name. For example,
changing the window title to "diff -u localFile remoteFile" would be
clearer. The first two lines of the diff window provide the name of the
two files.
What does "unisondiff-" say? Nothing! On the contrary, "remoteFile" is
explicit.
If you still think I am wrong, you can close the bug...
To sum up, i am not sure changing this behavior will really improve
usability.
Regards
Sylvain Le Gall
ps: diff-ing two files can be confusing even with what you propose
pps: if you really want you can set your own diff command, that will do
exactly what you ask (see unison documentation)
Yes, I saw, thank you. This is for changing 1st and 2nd file, but not
to have more explicit names.
--
Eugen Dedu
