* Tore Anderson

>  What issue is there that needs to be solved, exactly?

* Marc Haber

> A potentially dangerous security issue.

  The code path from accepting to closing a connection according to the
 cidr_deny/deny configuration statements is fairly short and obvious so
 I'm sceptic as to whether this is a real concern or merely an academic
 one.  If such a bug does exist, however, the issue would be critical
 regardless of the default configuration, as it could still be exploited
 by a user capable of connecting to 127.0.0.1, and in very many setups
 the node would be reconfigured to listen on all interfaces anyway
 (after all, it's what it's made for).

  I also note that packages such as Apache and others appear to employ
 a similar strategy as munin-node - listen on all interfaces, but
 restrict access to potentially sensitive data or functionality by way
 of application-specific access control lists.

  Listening on all interfaces was recently made the documented default
 (see <http://munin.projects.linpro.no/changeset/1186>), too..  It's of
 course possible to change this (at least in the developement trunk), so
 I'll have a talk to Nicolai and point him to this bug log, and let him
 decide if the default should be changed or not - I'll respect his
 choice, and consider merging any eventual change in trunk to the 1.2.x
 branch.

  (Oh and by the way, I fully agree that not having the loopback
 interface available inside a vserver sucks...)

Regards
-- 
Tore Anderson



-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to