Hi Reinhard,

Thank you for your response to my bug report.

The bug was indeed solved upstream and made available in testing. I confirm that the version in testing solves my problem (I tested it today), however I'd like to kindly motivate my request to have this bug fix (and the corresponding new podman version) backported in stable, since you invite me do to so.

I understand that your criteria as Debian package maintainers for merging such updates in stable are high, and that's what I appreciate about Debian and which gives it its reliability. This problem isn't a critical security vulnerability, but it is from my point of view an important, if not critical, regression.

For a server running production projects on Debian 12, this issue makes upgrading a difficult process as it forces one to both perform the distribution upgrade and to migrate hosted projects to quadlets at the same time (or to use the official compose implementation, but as I wrote previously it as some other drawbacks). I think the Debian upgrade process should not lead to forward-incompatibility issues when a working, compatible solution is known, and that if such an incompatibility is detected and acknowledged at some point, then it's probably better to either fix the incompatible package or to warn users.

My point here is to highlight the fact that users may not be aware of this issue; they might (rightly so) expect the provided version to work (modulo breaking changes available to everyone in podman changelog), and end up with a difficult to reproduce bug, since the problematic behavior is intermittent. This does not seem to me to be in line with the Debian philosophy where compatibility is thoroughly evaluated.

Finally, since podman is a rapidly evolving software whose recent versions fix many bugs and introduce useful features, I think backporting would be beneficial for Debian stable users when such bugs are found.

Maybe one sub problem here is that we don't have good alternative repos (AFAIK) to use more recent podman versions on Debian 13 (maybe alvistack's repos?).

Please don't take those motivating elements as criticism, I totally understand that finding all bugs is not possible, and I would be happy to help conduct further evaluation if needed.

Thanks for your work!

Best regards,

Léo

Reply via email to