Thank you for the report. I will try to reproduce on my setup. I only use ssh to connect to my Amanda clients. No Trixie yet on server.
On August 21, 2025 1:36:05 PM GMT+01:00, Alexandre Maret <[email protected]> wrote: >Package: amanda-server >Version: 1:3.5.4-2 >Severity: important > >Dear Maintainer, > >After upgrading from bookworm to trixie, any unreachable DLE accessed >over ssh will cause the planner to fail and the whole amdump job to fail >with MISSING status for every DLE. > >Removing all offending DLEs from the disklist will let the amdump proceed >correctly, including dumping DLEs reachable over ssh. > >From that known working config, consider the following: > >- Re-adding a single DLE for a host that is unreachable will again cause > the planner to fail and the whole amdump to fail, with every DLE > reporting MISSING. > This is a regression from bookworm. > >- Adding a DLE for an unresolvable hostname, with a bsdtcp dumptype will > correctly report a problem with that DLE only, the amdump will proceed > as expected. > >- Switching the dumptype of that unresolvable hostname DLE to one with > auth=ssh will again cause the planner to fail and the whole amdump to > fail. > >Those last 2 steps should provide an easy way to reproduce the bug. > >end of the planner debug log: > >Thu Aug 21 12:55:05.838597743 2025: pid 23653: thd-0x55f7b31ffd20: planner: >security_stream_seterr(0x7f3208000ea0, SOCKET_EOF) >Thu Aug 21 12:55:05.838722131 2025: pid 23653: thd-0x55f7b31ffd20: planner: >security_seterror(handle=0x7f3208000b90, driver=0x7f320f0dd2c0 (SSH) error=EOF >on read from failure-host) >Thu Aug 21 12:55:05.838890713 2025: pid 23653: thd-0x55f7b35237e0: planner: >make_socket opening socket with family 2 >Thu Aug 21 12:55:05.838915702 2025: pid 23653: thd-0x55f7b31ffd20: planner: >security_close(handle=0x7f3208000b90, driver=0x7f320f0dd2c0 (SSH)) >Thu Aug 21 12:55:05.838956236 2025: pid 23653: thd-0x55f7b31ffd20: planner: >security_stream_close(0x7f3208000ea0) >Thu Aug 21 12:55:05.838974323 2025: pid 23653: thd-0x55f7b31ffd20: planner: >security_stream_seterr(0x7f3208000ea0, write error to: Broken pipe) >Thu Aug 21 12:55:05.838980868 2025: pid 23653: thd-0x55f7b35237e0: planner: >make_socket opening socket with family 2: 15 > >Additionally, amcheck will exit early with a disklist containing >problematic ssh DLEs, without correctly reporting the problem. It will not >output any "Amanda Backup Client Hosts Check" section, though the >error "ssh: Could not resolve hostname failure-host: Name or service not >known" will be in the server host check section. > >From the amcheck log: > >Thu Aug 21 14:10:26.865704522 2025: pid 24345: thd-0x55fce5fb4d20: >amcheck-clients: security_stream_seterr(0x7f25d4000eb0, SOCKET_EOF) >Thu Aug 21 14:10:26.865817464 2025: pid 24345: thd-0x55fce5fb4d20: >amcheck-clients: security_seterror(handle=0x7f25d4000b90, >driver=0x7f25da63a2c0 (SSH) error=EOF on read from failure-host) >Thu Aug 21 14:10:26.867692353 2025: pid 24345: thd-0x55fce5fb4d20: >amcheck-clients: new message: amcheck.c:2602:16:2800206 failure-host: >selfcheck request failed: EOF on read from failure-host >Thu Aug 21 14:10:26.867893331 2025: pid 24345: thd-0x55fce5fb4d20: >amcheck-clients: Not value for key 'dle_hostname' in message , > { > "source_filename" : "amcheck.c", > "source_line" : "2602", > "severity" : "error", > "process" : "amcheck-clients", > "running_on" : "amanda-server", > "component" : "amanda", > "module" : "amanda", > "code" : "2800206", > "hostname" : "failure-host", > "errstr" : "EOF on read from failure-host", > "message" : "failure-host: selfcheck request failed: EOF on read from > failure-host" > } >Thu Aug 21 14:10:26.868087190 2025: pid 24345: thd-0x55fce5fb4d20: >amcheck-clients: security_close(handle=0x7f25d4000b90, driver=0x7f25da63a2c0 >(SSH)) >Thu Aug 21 14:10:26.868119460 2025: pid 24345: thd-0x55fce5fb4d20: >amcheck-clients: security_stream_close(0x7f25d4000eb0) >Thu Aug 21 14:10:26.868204737 2025: pid 24345: thd-0x55fce5fb4d20: >amcheck-clients: security_stream_seterr(0x7f25d4000eb0, write error to: Broken >pipe) > >Switching the offending DLE dumptype to a non ssh type will correctly produce >the following output: > >Amanda Backup Client Hosts Check >-------------------------------- >ERROR: failure-host: selfcheck request failed: resolve_hostname(failure-host): >Name or service not known > >It will also report problems with other clients, which it didn't when >the problematic failure-host DLE was type=ssh. > > >-- System Information: >Debian Release: 13.0 > APT prefers stable-updates > APT policy: (500, 'stable-updates'), (500, 'stable-security'), (500, > 'stable') >Architecture: amd64 (x86_64) > >Kernel: Linux 6.12.41+deb13-amd64 (SMP w/12 CPU threads; PREEMPT) >Locale: LANG=en_US.UTF-8, LC_CTYPE=en_US.UTF-8 (charmap=UTF-8), >LANGUAGE=en_US:en >Shell: /bin/sh linked to /usr/bin/dash >Init: systemd (via /run/systemd/system) >LSM: AppArmor: enabled > >Versions of packages amanda-server depends on: >ii amanda-common 1:3.5.4-2 >ii bsd-mailx [mailx] 8.1.2-0.20220412cvs-1.1 >ii libc6 2.41-12 >ii libcurl4t64 8.14.1-2 >ii libglib2.0-0t64 2.84.3-1 >ii libjson-perl 4.10000-1 >ii perl 5.40.1-6 > >amanda-server recommends no packages. > >Versions of packages amanda-server suggests: >ii amanda-client 1:3.5.4-2 >ii cpio 2.15+dfsg-2 >pn gnuplot <none> > >-- no debconf information
