Followup-For: Bug #952450 X-Debbugs-Cc: [email protected], [email protected]
As an experiment, I recently updated a functional Debian bookworm system to boot into the systemd 'rescue.target' by default, to test the single-user / recovery experience as part of #1035543 bug assessment. My understanding from the relevant manual[1] is that 'emergency.target' is a similar, albeit even more basic systemd state that is automatically selected if early boot preconditions fail and/or when serious errors occur. The system used for testing has a locked root user account, but is essentially a single-user environment, as I think is typical for many individually-operated laptops, smartphones and other consumer computing devices. There are various considerations to balance here, and because some of those are context/usage-specific, I agree with Raphaël that a debconf question to figure out the intended behaviour would make sense. My understanding of it is something like: "when your system breaks for some reason, are you ok with the next person who reboots it -- yourself or anyone else -- being able to access the contents and potentially attempt recovery?" Most of my experience with that scenario has been that either I or some other process has broken my computer, and I'd generally much prefer to be able to get to a recovery prompt without having to use other more time-consuming methods like removing the disk or finding other ways to get back into the system; but I can understand that those kind of choices vary person-to-person and over time. [1] - https://manpages.debian.org/bullseye/systemd/systemd.special.7.en.html
