Le dim. 22 sept. 2019 à 15:54, Mauro Carvalho Chehab <[email protected]> a écrit : > > Em Sun, 22 Sep 2019 13:20:42 +0200 > Gregor Jasny <[email protected]> escreveu: > > > Hello Mauro, > > > > Do you have an idea why scanning fails here? > > See comments below. > > Btw, not sure how often Debian updates the dtv-scan-tables package. This > package contains only configuration settings to be used for Digital TV > (and a Makefile with installs their contents at the right places), > and it is updated upstream a few times per year, in order to reflect > the current channel listings, as, from time to time, new frequencies > are used, tuning parameters change or satellites got replaced. > > I strongly suggest to update this package from time to time, even on > a LTS distro. > > Based on the report, it sounds that Clément is still using a very old > channel table, with the channel frequencies used before March 2015. > The channel parameters were updated in 2017 at frequency database > tree, and the file itself was renamed in 2018, in order to follow > the current name for the satellite: Eutelsat 5 West A.
Yes, the issue is actually with dts-scan-tables. I downloaded Eutelsat-5-West-A-5.0W from the repository you linked and it scan channels now. I checked packages.debian.org and even sid has the same version for dts-scan-tables. I don't really know how bug are managed here, can you reclassify it as a dts-scan-tables bug? > > > On 22.09.19 10:25, Clément Vuchener wrote: > > > > I am trying to receive DVB-S2 using a Hauppauge WinTV Starbust 2 tuner > > > card. dvbv5-scan fails to find anything and always report status 00, > > > while w_scan successfully scanned channels. As reportbug asked me to use > > > the latest version, I installed sid versions of dvb-tools and libdvbv5-0 > > > on my Debian Buster installation, but this did not change the result. > > > > > > $ dvbv5-scan -l universal /usr/share/dvb/dvb-s/Atlantic-Bird-3-5.0W > > > Using LNBf UNIVERSAL > > > Old European Universal. Nowadays mostly replaced by Astra 19.2E > > > Freqs : 10800 to 11800 MHz, LO: 9750 MHz > > > Freqs : 11600 to 12700 MHz, LO: 10600 MHz > > First of all, the best is to use the "extended" LNBf, as this is the most > common LNBf found in Europe those days. It has a wider frequency range. > If you use "universal", you won't be able to tune a few transponders there, > with have a frequency a little higher than 12,700 MHz. My LNB is old, but I'll check. It worked with the "universal" settings, and the channel I am interested in are in the universal range any way. > > Also, looking a w_scan source code, S5W0 is not Atlantic Bird, but, instead, > EUTELSAT 5 WEST A, with was renamed at DTV scan tables [1] in 2018: > > commit 740c6b2eb7ad8c9ff77a2d8cc6811d6dbfa201c3 > Author: Olliver Schinagl <[email protected]> > Date: Thu May 10 21:41:13 2018 +0200 > > Rename Atlantic Bird 3 to Eutelsat5 > > [1] see https://git.linuxtv.org/dtv-scan-tables.git > > The scan table for it was also changed in 2017: > > commit 3dc7a8d6b5f9a8218ac3763c3a4d5cc86100c5a0 > Author: [email protected] <[email protected]> > Date: Wed Jan 11 14:28:51 2017 +0100 > > dtv-scan-tables - dvb-s - update and rename the config file for > Atlantic-Bird-3-5.0W - Ku Band > > Hello, > > The latest update for the file Atlantic-Bird-3-5.0W (Ku Band) is > 2015-03-28: > https://git.linuxtv.org/dtv-scan-tables.git/log/dvb-s/Atlantic-Bird-3-5.0W > but since March 2015 there are a lot of changes in the tranponders list. > And now, a lot of transponders for Algerian, French and Italian TV and > Radio channels are missing. > Attached is an updated config scan file (Atlantic-Bird-3-5.0W.patch > file) for Atlantic-Bird-3-5.0W transponders in dvbv5 format. > Could you please ensure that this new patch is committed into the DVB > source code tree repositery? > PS : Attached there is also the full up to date file : > Atlantic-Bird-3-5.0W-2017-01-09.NEW.FULL if you need it > > Btw, on a quick look at w_scan code, it uses those frequencies: > > {5, 10971, 1, 29950, 7 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 48.3Mbps; NID=1375 ; TID=20600; > {5, 11017, 0, 2048 , 5 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 3.1Mbps; NID=65500; TID=1 ; > {5, 11054, 1, 29950, 7 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 48.3Mbps; NID=1375 ; TID=20500; > {5, 11059, 0, 23700, 3 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 32.8Mbps; NID=1374 ; TID=10900; > {5, 11096, 1, 29950, 7 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 48.3Mbps; NID=1375 ; TID=20400; > {5, 11103, 0, 2043 , 5 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 3.1Mbps; NID=65500; TID=1 ; > {5, 11115, 0, 2725 , 5 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 1.0 bps; NID=0 ; TID=0 ; > {5, 11139, 1, 27540, 2 , 0, 9 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 0.0 bps; NID=8442 ; TID=4 ; > {5, 11157, 0, 2720 , 5 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 4.2Mbps; NID=65500; TID=1 ; > {5, 11177, 0, 2043 , 5 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 3.1Mbps; NID=65500; TID=1 ; > {6, 11471, 1, 29950, 2 , 3, 9 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 58.0Mbps; NID=1374 ; TID=20100; > {5, 11472, 0, 2444 , 5 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 3.8Mbps; NID=2823 ; TID=2739 ; > {5, 11509, 0, 27500, 2 , 0, 9 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 0.0 bps; NID=0 ; TID=0 ; > {5, 11512, 1, 29950, 7 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 48.3Mbps; NID=1375 ; TID=20200; > {5, 11538, 0, 8681 , 7 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 14.0Mbps; NID=100 ; TID=101 ; > {5, 11555, 1, 29950, 7 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 48.3Mbps; NID=1375 ; TID=20300; > {5, 11591, 1, 20000, 2 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 24.6Mbps; NID=8442 ; TID=1 ; > {5, 11609, 1, 5969 , 1 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 20.7Kbps; NID=0 ; TID=0 ; > {5, 11679, 1, 29950, 7 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 48.3Mbps; NID=1375 ; TID=20800; > {5, 12543, 0, 27500, 3 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 38.0Mbps; NID=2049 ; TID=9201 ; > {5, 12711, 0, 30000, 1 , 0, 0 }, // EUTELSAT 5 WEST A 0 > ; 27.6Mbps; NID=65535; TID=1 ; > > There are several transponders missing there at Ku band, when compared > with the current content of the file upstream: > > > https://git.linuxtv.org/dtv-scan-tables.git/tree/dvb-s/Eutelsat-5-West-A-5.0W > > So, in other words, you should use the latest table from dtv-scan-tables, > and do: > > $ dvbv5-scan -l extended /usr/share/dvb/dvb-s/Eutelsat5_5.0W > > > Thanks, > Mauro
