Hi Daniel,

On Thu, 2017-02-16 at 13:54 -0500, Daniel Kahn Gillmor wrote:
> Package: ui-auto
> Version: 1.2.9

(...)

> the debrsign workflow isn't a particularly safe one (see discussion
> on
> https://bugs.debian.org/855282 and https://bugs.debian.org/855320).
> 
> ui-auto should not encourage its use, and should probably either
> explicitly deprecate or just drop support for the debrsign option.
> 
> Additionally, ui-auto-rsign seems to encourage the same dubious
> workflow of making ssh connections from untrusted machines to trusted
> machines.  It should probably be deprecated or removed as well.

thx for the note :).

ui-auto is not actively developed any more, it's basically 'compat-
maintained' for projects still using it -- i.e., I do not much like
dropping functionality.

Would it be sufficient to add appropriate warnings

- in the example user.conf (*_rsign and *_debrsign options)
- when *_rsign resp. *_debrsign are called (as warning log)
- when ui-auto-rsign is called (as warning log)

?

Fwiw, both options (rsign or debrsign) are disabled by default and need
explicit configuration by the user.

Thx!

Stephan

Reply via email to