02.11.2014 19:11, Daniel Lindgren wrote:
> 2014-11-02 12:41 GMT+01:00 Michael Tokarev <[email protected] 
> <mailto:[email protected]>>:
> 
>     > Obviuously not an operator error. There has been a dependency for 
> bridge-utils in the past, that depency has now been removed which causes apt 
> to mark bridge-utils as not needed when it clearly still is in use, as it was 
> on my installation.
> 
>     So what do you suggest?  To keep old and long obsolete
>     dependencies as dependencies forever?
> 
> 
> I suggest that changes to packages that could break networking are at least 
> documented. I have checked the changelog for qemu-kvm and I can't find any 
> reference to bridge-utils being removed. There wasn't any info in listed 
> changes during the upgrade either.

The change _is_ documented. qemu-kvm source package does not
exist anymore (the one which was using bridge-utils long time
ago) -- there's a NEWS item about this.  It might be too implicit
indeed, because there's no information about that new source
means no bridge-utils package.  I dunno.  Even for the old
qemu-kvm _source_ package, bridge-utils was only in Recommends,
and that wasn't because it was needed by qemu-kvm, but because
qemu was able to use it if it's installed.  Now qemu-kvm binary
package is built from qemu source package, and that one never,
ever, had a bridge-utils dependency.

[]
> I consider not documenting the removal of a dependency - leading to a 
> possible removal of a package that could break networking - a bug. What you 
> do with the filed bug is up to you.

The bug is closed since my first reply, and this is my last
reply to this bugreport.

Thanks,

/mjt


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [email protected]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [email protected]

Reply via email to