Package: wnpp
Severity: wishlist

* Package name    : screencloud
  Version         : 1.1.6
  Upstream Author : Olav Sortland Thoresen <olav.s...@gmail.com>
* URL             : http://www.screencloud.net (online service)
                    http://www.github.com/olav-st/screencloud (source)
* License         : GPL2 or any later version
  Programming Lang: C++ / Qt
  Description     : easy to use screenshot tool

Screencloud allows taking a screenshot of the full screen, a window or a
manually selected screen region. It offers various advanced settings like
adding a delay before taking the screenshot, hotkeys, and optionally sharing
the screenshot through (S)FTP, the screencloud online service or similar
services.


Relevant information (similar packages, reason for RFP etc.):

Shutter offers the same features and quite a bit more. I'm a little concerned
about the future of shutter though, as it still depends on Gtk2 and other
gnome2 libraries and there's not much activity in the usptream bzr repository.
At the same time, screencloud still depends on Qt4. There's some activity in
the upstream git repo though, and I imagine porting from Qt4 to Qt5 is easier
than porting from Gtk2 to Gtk3 and libgnome2-* to whatever the new libraries
are called.

While screencloud is less feature-rich than shutter, it has a nicer user
interface and is less overwhelming for the average user. I prefer it over
shutter and would therefore love to see it in Debian.

Caveats:

- Screencloud apparently downloads a list of sharing plugins and offers them
  for "installation" on first start. This is almost certainly not ideal for
  packaging in Debian, it probably has security implications as well. This
  functionality should probably be patched out of the eventual Debian package
  and desired plugins should be included with the package.

- Likewise, there's a check for updates in the preferences dialog and an
  automatic update check. It should probably be patched out of the package,
  too.

- Since the tool was created by the owner of the screencloud online service, it
  advertises creating an account there to share screenshots. While this seems
  to be completely optional and the tool is open source and very useful even
  without having an account, it may or may not conflict with some Debian
  policies.

- There might be more caveats related to the "proprietary open source" nature
  of this software.


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org

Reply via email to