On Sun, Aug 27, 2006 at 03:20:54PM -0400, Joey Hess wrote:
> Jens Seidel wrote:
> > I can now reproduce it and found also the problem:
> > APT is not able to mount a Debian CD, since APT searchs by default in
> > /cdrom (see #282344) but /target/etc/fstab refers to /media/cdrom0.
> > Setting Acquire::cdrom::mount "/media/cdrom0" in /target/etc/apt/apt.conf
> > fixes this.
>
> d-i creates a /cdrom -> /media/cdrom0 link, specifially to keep apt happy.
It's not so easy. First of all, apt-cdrom(8) mentions that
"This mount point must be listed in /etc/fstab". This may be wrong as
mount seems first to follow symlinks before looking in fstab, i.e.
mount /cdrom mounts /media/cdrom0 not /cdrom (even if it's contained in
fstab). According to the man page, a later "apt-cdrom add" called by the
user requires option "-d".
> So the question seems to be, why isn't that working for apt in /target?
>
> > To reproduce it use the Beta 3 netinst ISO ("install" target) and
> > install a system without network mirror. Once the installation finished
> > the CD is unmounted. Now select again "Select and install software" and
> > try to install another task. The system hangs now because APT cannot
> > mount the CD. The same happens if the user unmout the CD manually ...
>
> Ok, so you're going all the way thru to the end of the installation process,
> which unmounts and ejects the CD, canceling when it says it's going to reboot,
(It doesn't prompt when rebooting in standard mode, I stop the process
during the bootloader setup.)
> and then going back and running pkgsel again.
Yes.
> The problem might be that base-installer adds this to apt.conf.d:
>
> APT::CDROM::NoMount "true";
> Acquire::cdrom {
> mount "/cdrom";
> "/cdrom/" {
> Mount "true";
> UMount "true";
> };
> }
Indeed. I verified this.
> And it's not removed until the very end of the installation. So if you
> cancel and go back, you're left with an unmounted CD, and with apt configured
> to never try to mount the CD.
I tried to start aptitude from the console and noticed that
APT::CDROM::NoMount "true";
has no effect. Even after removing this line (or using "false") apt
fails to mount the CD (even after the following fix!).
The problem is the line '"/cdrom/" {'. Remove the trailing slash and it
works like a charm:
"/cdrom" {
Whether you add a slash to 'mount "/cdrom";' (to make both entries
consistent) is unimportant and has no effect.
The German book Debian-Anwenderhandbuch mentions that this slash is
important, see http://debiananwenderhandbuch.de/apt.conf.html ("You need
the trailing slash!") so it seems it was indeed necessary in the past?
Why do you use
Mount "true";
UMount "true";
"true" is the no-op command (not a boolean value!?) and useless!?
> If so, then moving base-installer's finish-install script to run before
> cdrom-detect's would solve the problem. It could be tested by
> removing /target/etc/apt/apt.conf.d/00NoMountCDROM by hand and seeing it
> pkgsel worked then. I'm not currently able to test this.
Jens
--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
