On 12/11/2026 at 21:57, Alper Nebi Yasak wrote:
On 2026-11-08 16:49 +03:00, Pascal Hambourg wrote:
On 06/11/2026 at 13:40, Alper Nebi Yasak wrote:
I guess ESP logic would make the "do not
use" interpretation more consistent with other partman-* packages, which
sounds good.
Actually only partman-efi implements this logic. Setting an ESP "do not
use" is required to prevent the installer from possibly formatting and
mounting it, but we do not want it to clear the original ESP flag.
IIUC ChromeOS is different. Partman does not really "use" (format or
mount) a ChromeOS partition, it just sets the type flag on it and checks
if such partition is present on the boot/root disk. And we may actually
want manual "do not use" to clear the flag.
So ESP and ChromeOS partitions may need different interpretations of "do
not use".
The "flag" here sets the GPT Partition Type GUID for the partition (a bad
extension of a legacy abstraction), and only one such flag makes sense on
any partition, and having none means it defaults to whatever parted likes
(Linux data?, I forgot).
If no partition type flag is set, the default partition type depends on
the selected or detected filesystem (another parted oddity):
- fat, ntfs, udf -> Microsoft basic data
- hfs -> Apple HFS
- linux-swap -> Linux swap
- freebsd-ufs -> FreeBSD UFS (Debian patch)
- other or none -> Linux filesystem data
(source: parted/libparted/labels/gpt.c)
So to clear these flags, it may arguably be better
to explicitly select to use them as something else?
I'm afraid not, because some methods do not explicitly set a partition
type flag and implicitly remove the previous flag:
- filesystem
- swap
- physical volume for encryption
Maybe we need a "Empty partition" method that clears these flags, and
maybe zeros out the first MiB of a partition so it has no filesystem.
That would resolve the ambiguity of "Do not use" where we would always
keep the partition as-is.
partman-crypto already provides a "erase partition data" choice in the
active partition menu. But what is the point of keeping a partition,
clearing its flags, erasing its contents and not using it for anything
instead of just deleting the partition ?
Maybe codifying "Do not use" as a value in the method file ("keep/efi"
for example, where we can also have the old method info) could help?
It could make things a bit simpler, maybe. But which "old" method should
be recorded ? The original (on disk) one or the current selected one
(like method-old set by partman-auto) ?