Christian PERRIER left as an exercise for the reader: > I'd like to followup on your suggestion as it seems well thought and > prepared and not just one idea thrown in the wild as I was initially > thinking (sorry for this).
Thanks for your kind words, christian! i'm still wondering what people think
about installing GRUB to all disks (thus making boots more deterministic (see
my mail to this group of 2012-10-13 [0])), but I think this change would be
more valuable still.
> You have well identified the difficulty in abandoning partman. The
> main "problem" is probably that partman is well modular and makes it
> "easy" to throw in some new fliesystem support (it seems this is not
I'd say it's simpler to add a filesystem to growlight's c code than the scripts
of partman, personally (I know I'm sounding kinda like Lennart here, but hey,
SprezzOS uses systemd). Here's the fs dispatch table [1], used for creation,
setting a UUID (where appropriate), and setting a label (where appropriate):
static const struct fs {
const char *name;
const char *desc;
int (*mkfs)(const char *,const struct mkfsmarshal *);
int (*uuidset)(const char *,const unsigned char *);
char nameparam; // parameter on cmdline to name
int namemax; // max length of name, if known
} fss[] = {
{
.name = "vfat",
.desc = "File Allocation Table (DOS default)",
.mkfs = vfat_mkfs,
.namemax = 11,
.nameparam = 'n',
.uuidset = NULL,
},
etc etc. Take a look -- I think you'll find the C very readable.
> "easy" to throw in some new fliesystem support (it seems this is not
> as easy as it seems, though, as you ended up in developing something
> else for ZFS support).
ZFS is a combination of the block layer and filesystem layer. It was going to
require special cases in most any system. Indeed, it gets a whole (small) file
and device class in growlight [2].
I didn't end up using partman because partman is ugly, partman's source is
ugly, partman seems unusable with a large number of drives (I regularly deal
with 128 drives in a machine), partman didn't have UEFI support at the time,
I found d-i debconf scripts difficult to debug, and I need curved unicode
box characters to live.
> It is quite easy, though to push for your proposal : develop growlight
> and the udebs it produces in the D-I infrastructure, eventually
As said, you can find a growlight udeb in the SprezzOS repositories, where it
is actively used in our d-i-derived installer:
[skynet](0) $ links2 -dump
https://www.sprezzatech.com/apt/pool/main/g/growlight/
Index of /apt/pool/main/g/growlight
[ICO] Name Last Size
Description
modified
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
[DIR] Parent Directory -
[ ] growlight-udeb_1.0.4.5-SprezzOS2_amd64.udeb 06-Feb-2013 122K 04:26
[ ] growlight_1.0.4.5-SprezzOS2.debian.tar.gz 06-Feb-2013 4.6K 04:26
[ ] growlight_1.0.4.5-SprezzOS2.dsc 06-Feb-2013 2.2K 04:26
[ ] growlight_1.0.4.5-SprezzOS2_amd64.deb 06-Feb-2013 208K 04:26
[ ] growlight_1.0.4.5.orig.tar.xz 06-Feb-2013 388K 04:26
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apache/2.2.22 (Debian) Server at www.sprezzatech.com Port 443
[skynet](0) $ dpkg-deb -I growlight-udeb_1.0.4.5-SprezzOS2_amd64.udeb
new debian package, version 2.0.
size 128482 bytes: control archive=1301 bytes.
828 bytes, 14 lines control
1092 bytes, 39 lines * postinst #!/bin/sh
118 bytes, 4 lines templates
Package: growlight-udeb
Source: growlight
Version: 1.0.4.5-SprezzOS2
Architecture: amd64
Installer-Menu-Item: 4200
Maintainer: Nick Black <nick.bl...@sprezzatech.com>
Installed-Size: 468
Depends: cdebconf-udeb, hw-detect, md-modules, mdadm-udeb, dmsetup-udeb,
libpci3-udeb, libcryptsetup4-udeb, libatasmart4-udeb, libpciaccess0-udeb,
kbd-udeb, e2fsprogs-udeb, dosfstools-udeb, jfsutils-udeb, xfsprogs-udeb,
ntfs-3g-udeb, btrfs-tools-udeb, hfsutils-udeb, f2fs-tools-udeb, util-linux-udeb
Replaces: grub-installer, lilo-installer, partitioner, partman
Provides: bootable-system, created-fstab, harddrive-detection,
made-filesystems, made-swapspace, mounted-partitions, partitioned-harddrives
Section: debian-installer
Priority: standard
Description: Prepare target
Growlight udeb, unsuitable for installation on normal machines.
[skynet](0) $
Obviously this is not going to land for Wheezy, but it seems that this provides
a pretty decent starting point for the beginning of the next development epoch.
Thanks!
-rigorously, nick
Hacker in Charge, SprezzOS Project
[0] http://lists.debian.org/debian-boot/2012/10/msg00184.html
[1] https://github.com/dankamongmen/growlight/blob/master/src/fs.c
[2] https://github.com/dankamongmen/growlight/blob/master/src/zfs.c
--
nick black http://www.sprezzatech.com -- unix and hpc consulting
to make an apple pie from scratch, you need first invent a universe.
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature
