Hi Paul,
you said

> Grub install failed:
>   - proposes to install on first hard drive (as always)
>   - but first hard drive was the USB stick
>   - install failed, USB stick not damaged (whew)
>   - post installation:
>     - regenerated device map and reinstalled grub bootloader
> 
> Is there a good point during the install to remove the USB stick
> to ensure the real disk is detected as the first hard drive ?

and then closed the bug since the installation was successful overall.
I have a question for the list - why should this be considered a success?

Isn't the correct behaviour for grub-install to
 - propose to install on disk drive other than the install medium
  (there may be cases where this isn't right)
or else
 - propose to install on first hard drive
 - but then allow user to select another drive for the install
or else
 - list all drives it detects
 - ask the user to mark any removable drives (so they will be ignored
   when compiling the device map)
 - propose to install to the first of the remaining drives
 - but then allow user to select another of the remaining drives for the install

Can you clarify a point for me also - when the installer sets up the /
partition in /etc/fstab, does it set it up to mount by UUID, or as
device /dev/sda1?

Perhaps I've misunderstood something here but it seems like there are
still issues with grub-install that would be quite significant for users
less expert than yourself.

Kind regards
Vince


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-boot-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org
Archive: http://lists.debian.org/20130123112123.ga14...@mayhem.atnf.csiro.au

Reply via email to