Dear James, Thank you very much for your very kind and detailed reply.
Using your recommendations, I managed to install Trilinos + MueLu working with deal.ii master. Thank you very much for your help with this! The only thing I had to change from the default recipe here https://github.com/dealii/dealii/wiki/Apple-ARM-M1-OSX to make it work for me is adding: -D Tpetra_INST_INT_INT=ON \ on line 236 of the file candi/deal.II-toolchain/packages/trilinos.package Thanks again and best regards, Nik On Wednesday, January 8, 2025 at 6:29:51 PM UTC+1 avfa...@gmail.com wrote: Dear Nik, I’ve been working with deal.II and Trilinos (including MueLu) across various platforms, including macOS, for a while now. I understand your frustration, as the installation and configuration process can be tricky. Let me briefly share some insights based on my experience. *Key Issues:* 1. *Epetra vs. Tpetra Transition*: Trilinos is phasing out the Epetra stack in favor of Tpetra. However, deal.II’s Trilinos wrapper is still in transition, meaning some functionalities and interfaces are incomplete. This transitional state often leads to compatibility issues, especially with advanced features like MueLu. 2. *MueLu Configuration Challenges*: MueLu’s compatibility depends heavily on the configuration of Epetra/Tpetra and the global ordinal type (e.g., int vs. long long). Unfortunately, these compatibility nuances are not always well-documented. Both the deal.II and Trilinos GitHub repositories have issues discussing these challenges, which might eventually resolve as the Epetra-to-Tpetra transition progresses (hopefully by 2025–2026). *My Experience:* I’ve successfully installed deal.II with Trilinos and MueLu on CentOS clusters and Apple Silicon macOS using various compiler toolchains (GCC, Intel icpc, Apple Clang). However, the process was rarely straightforward. For my most recent setup on macOS, I didn’t strictly follow the steps outlined in the Apple-ARM-M1-OSX guide <https://github.com/dealii/dealii/wiki/Apple-ARM-M1-OSX>. Instead, I used a customized toolchain: the latest GCC (installed via Homebrew, mainly for gfortran, as macOS doesn’t provide it natively) and OpenMPI, combined with macOS’s default Clang as the C++ compiler. Using this setup, I built the master versions of both deal.II and Trilinos with *candi*. To ensure compatibility, I manually edited the Trilinos.package file in candi, explicitly activating nearly the entire Tpetra stack (Tpetra, Ifpack2, MueLu, Belos, Amesos2, Zoltan2) along with their corresponding Epetra stack. After some adjustments, everything compiled successfully, and I was able to run MueLu-based AMG preconditioners with dealii-assembled-matrices without issues. *Recommendations:* 1. *Custom Configuration*: If you’re using candi, consider modifying the Trilinos configuration manually to ensure both Tpetra and Epetra are fully activated. Ensure you use compatible global ordinals and enable relevant packages like MueLu and Belos. 2. *GitHub Issues*: I recommend opening an issue on the deal.II GitHub repository. Several developers are actively working on the Tpetra wrapper and may have more up-to-date knowledge about MueLu configuration rules. Apologies for not being able to provide detailed instructions at this time—I’ve been quite busy lately. I hope this helps as a starting point, and I’m happy to share more insights if needed. Best regards, James 在2025年1月8日星期三 UTC+8 21:32:54<nikl...@stanford.edu> 写道： Dear User Group, I recently got a new Apple arm-based M4 laptop running Mac OS Sequoia. My previous laptop was running Windows and using the Windows Subsystem for Linux, I managed to install deal.ii together with all the packages I would like to use. Now, I tried to install deal.II on the new machine. I followed the guidlines here: https://github.com/dealii/dealii/wiki/Apple-ARM-M1-OSX and everything went perfectly fine except for a small but for me important detail. Deal.II couldn't be configured to use MueLu from Trilinos. MueLu was installed but the corresponding *error* message from candi_configure.log when running configure_20_trilinos.cmake shows that the support was disabled because the test didn't succeed. -- Performing Test TRILINOS_MUELU_IS_FUNCTIONAL -- Performing Test TRILINOS_MUELU_IS_FUNCTIONAL - Failed -- MueLu was found but is not usable through Epetra! Disabling MueLu support. I tried several other ways: - Docker: I also got the same error (i.e. module TrilinosWrappers::PreconditionAMGMueLu not defined) probably because of defined(DEAL_II_TRILINOS_WITH_MUELU) being false in trilinos_precondition.h when I used the most recent docker image for the arm based architecture. - prepackaged .dmg files (v9.6.0 sequoia arm) --> same thing - prepackaged .dmg files (v9.5.0 intel) --> also tried this with the hope that maybe in a Rosetta2 emulated terminal, this could work but got the same error and even more like this:*/Applications/deal.II.app/Contents/Resources/Libraries/include/boost/container_hash/hash.hpp:132:33 <http://deal.II.app/Contents/Resources/Libraries/include/boost/container_hash/hash.hpp:132:33>: **error: **no template named 'unary_function' in namespace 'std'; did you mean '__unary_function'? *132 | struct hash_base : std::unary_function<T, std::size_t> {}; Therefore I have two questions: 1. Do you see a way to fix the above, i.e. get the MueLu support working. 2. What would be a *brute force* way to get deal.ii working on an arm-based machine. Should I try to run the terminal under Rosetta2 emulation and try to install from source? Thank you very much in advance for your help and best regards, Nik -- The deal.II project is located at http://www.dealii.org/ For mailing list/forum options, see https://groups.google.com/d/forum/dealii?hl=en --- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "deal.II User Group" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dealii+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/dealii/43d29189-d3f2-400f-99e1-505fb25a5160n%40googlegroups.com.
