Hi,

Using 19x19 policy on 9x9 and 13x13 is effective.
But opposite is?
I made 9x9 policy from Aya's 10k playout/move selfplay.

Using 9x9 policy on 13x13 and 19x19
19x19 DCNNAyaF128from9x9    1799
13x13 DCNNAyaF128from9x9    1900
9x9   DCNN_AyaF128a558x1    2290

Using 19x19 policy on 9x9 and 13x13
19x19 DCNN_AyaF128a523x1    2345
13x13 DCNNAya795F128a523    2354
9x9   DCNN_AyaF128a523x1    2179

19x19 policy is similar strength on 13x13 and 166 Elo weaker on 9x9.
9x9 policy is 390 Elo weaker on 13x13, and 491 Elo weaker on 19x19.
It seems smaller board is more useless than bigger board...

Note:
All programs select maximum policy without search.
All programs use opening book.
19x19 policy is Filter128, Layer 12, without Batch Normalization.
9x9 policy is Filter128, Layer 11, without Batch Normalization.
19x19 policy is made from pro 78000 games, GoGoD.
9x9 policy is made from 10k/move. It is CGOS 2892(Aya797c_p1v1_10k).
Ratings are BayesElo.

Thanks,
Hiroshi Yamashita

_______________________________________________
Computer-go mailing list
Computer-go@computer-go.org
http://computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go

Reply via email to